I was served a 100% cab franc from WA blind the other day… and it tasted like chocolate cover cherries hit soaked in vanilla and alcohol, and not in a great way. I guessed it was a Malbec!
I have been shopping around for some of the suggested wines. So far I have been able to acquire a 2010 Barde Haut. As I am on call this weekend, it will have to wait until Monday evening.
From that list, try the Domaine de Chevalier. It’s the only wine he touches that I buy. It is mostly Cab/Merlot with 5% petite verdot.
Unless you like uber-ripe modern, I would avoid his St. Emilions.
Smith Haut Lafite may be a nice wine for you to try as well. It’s too modern for me, but nothing like his St Ems. It is 60/40 Cab/Merlot in some years, but can have minimal amounts of Cab Franc and/or petite verdot in the blend in other years. You will not notice it.
I opened a half bottle of the 2015 Ch. Tour Saint Christophe [St Emilion] and enjoyed it as a pre-prandial relaxant. It is - indeed - very modern but gets the balance between tannin, extraction, and ageability right. This bottle was brought over by Jeffrey Davies, who specializes in this style of rich Bordeaux, and is a name I trust on back labels as much as KLWM. I always know what I’m getting with his selections: lush modern 15% abv wines that punch far above their dollarweight. There is some cab franc in this blend, but it does not stick out in a herbal / minty / Loire way. I get a touch of heat on the nose, but I didn’t decant. It’s a blackfruited modern right bank, but even though it fits my typecast, I’m not as much a fan as professional critics seem to be, who universally love the property. Even the BWE board awarded some vintage of this house a WOTY award. Overall, I’d give this a B+.
PS: I’ve had happy results with cellaring (by accident) the same ownership group’s other St Emilion - Haut Brisson.