If you're wondering if Beaucastel Hommage is worth the uptick

I was lucky to get to try the 89 and 90 Hommage together last night. Both are wonderful wines but the ’90 is a bit less structured than the ’89. Both can be drunk now or cellared for many more years. I also had some ’90 regular Beau left from a previous flight and while I loved it when tasted in a previous flight, it came across as light especially in the mid-palate when compared to the two Hommage. Funny how a wine tastes in different settings.

With a line-up of the above and 90 and 98 Pegau Laurence, 97 Pegau Justine, 90 Bonneau Cuvee Speciale, ’00 Bonneau Celestin, the Hommage were clearly WOTN with the ’89 being just exceptional.

How were the Bonneaus? Kelly Walker also mentioned a few times that the 89 Hommage is great. Thanks for sharing.

The Celestin was drinking very well. I’m not sure it will get any better but will certainly hold. The 90 Speciale is a monster and changed a lot in the little time I had with it. The one regret was that I didn’t have a few hours to just spend time with that one. Someone opened a 96 DP Oeno at the end of the night and I got distracted. champagne.gif

But is it better than a Bandol?

How was the Justine?
I’ve always been curious if it was a special barrel or if she just bottled it for her daughter’s Birth year.
Also being 97’, how did it hold up?

Thanks

Agreed Paul - special wines from '89 and '90 for sure and wish I had more… That sounds like a fantastic dinner!

Justine was for her daughter’s birth year, and it was a total of 100 cases made. One Foudre, and 2 Barriques.
It was really, really good. Didn’t show the vintage that much. If you have it, drink it up. It’s all out now.

The 90 Speciale had a bit too much VA for me. I’m pretty sensitive to that unfortunately :frowning:
The 2000 was really good, well balanced.

The 90 Laurence was also excellent, and in another 10 years, the 98 Laurence will be amazing.

Love this stuff - wish I could have joined in!!! Isn’t it to hot there in NY for CDP neener? jk - it’s never to hot for those nicies!

Jonathan,

They probably would have shown better if it was Tucson warm but we had to make do.

Honestly, when we planned this we didn’t expect the heatwave. We had 4 or 5 champagnes to cool us off though.

Promise I won’t get laughed out of NYC if I think we should have a flight or two of CDP next time I’m there [cheers.gif]? Love the stuff - especially in the fall.

I don’t believe you. Open a few up and convince me next time I’m at your place. neener

Keith moved to DC so half the CdP haters are gone. We only have Jay Miller to contend with.

[snort.gif]

I love Pegau’s regular bottling to almost no end, but I got rid of all my Pegau Cuvee Laurence.

I had the Cuvee Justine (97) at Wilfred’s 50th. How is it drinking?