Has anybody started trying Bordeaux 2005s? What are your views?

Don’t you know me by now? I have ZERO willpower. Like none. I exist to please myself. Wait, that didn’t sound right.

2 Likes

Really liked this 2005 Gazin recently:

2 Likes

For somebody who drinks so much Loire wine, that can’t possibly be true. There is definitely a streak of masochism there.

2 Likes

Alfert??? NOOOO

This was pretty good last night


I made tandoori lamb lollipops and palak paneer to go with it

4 Likes

I have 4 of the 05 Rouget purchased on EP. Time to try one, Arv?

1 Like

A few months ago, I had a gorgeous Chateau D’Issan.

1 Like

I opened up an 05 Larcis Ducasse tonight. It needed a couple of hours to come around.

PNP. Deep crimson and black color. No signs of age. Currant, boysenberry, vanilla and spice on the nose. Tart, firm and gritty palate, dusty tannins and juicy finish. Seems over oaked, but I’ll let it sit for an hour.

Update after 2 hours. Still tannic for a right banker, but the palate definitely improved with air, the oak was less noticeable and drying while the texture loosened up and fleshed out.

3 Likes

Can’t believe I forgot this: 2005 Ferriere about a week ago, absolutely slamming. Super floral and some really nice tertiary development. Just awesome.

3 Likes

I had a 2005 Tertre Roteboeuf in the last days of 2022, and my impression was that it was still young, headlined by a battle between the fruit and mouth-drying tannins to see which would prevail.

1 Like

We bought a bottle of 2005 Langoa Barton after tasting it 5 or 6 years ago and opened it last winter. It was fabulous. Wish we had more!

3 Likes

One of the few vintages where the Langoa is better than the Leoville Barton.

1 Like

Pichon 05 a few years ago was too closed for me. I sold all of my Valandraud 05 about 5 years ago because of severe disappointment with the way it developed. But Clos Fourtet 05 was my wine of the year two years ago. I am not touching slow developers like Montrose or LLC, not even for science. Surprisingly, lower level wines like Domaine de l’A 05 or Petite Eglise 05 are really drinking well even now. I am not mentioning the many mid-level Margaux wines that I have drank with immense satisfaction in the last 8 years. Remarkable vintage for Margaux.

1 Like

How are you guys able to drink all this Bordeaux in the middle of summer?

4 Likes

Great. I have one bottle left of this.

1 Like

A/C?

4 Likes

We had the windows open yesterday for the first time in 2 months. It’s always 72 inside, and always bdx time at this house.

1 Like

It’s like 100/100 here

Isn’t it always 100/100 there?

Inside and outside