FS: 2015 Dujac Charmes-Chambertin—Price Update

[Tom_Reddick]

In any case. Thanks Tom for your invaluable critique and advice.

Ok I will admit it- epic response lol.

[Tom_Reddick]

If you consider Belmont, which is $350 and has 3 btls in stock to be a obscure mom and pop store. Then I don’t know what to tell ya. If you can’t afford $370, you can magically afford $330? Dude that’s not how this works.

Back to topic at hand- not saying Belmont is Mom and Pop- just pointing out there are many scenarios where just going off WS low does not make sense.

I know $370 is not the best price out there- but if I were living in Colorado and wanted the wine and a hassle-free handoff, I would probably go for this offer.

Honestly I was just surprised to see the piling on.

[Mark_Golodetz]

Given board rules, I won’t discuss this particular item, except to say that I think Dujac’s Charmes are way underpriced compared to his other wines.

As a general rule I price using a combination of low Wine Searcher and Wine Market Journal which gives me the auction data. Unless I know the person, I would prefer to buy from a store, with all its protections rather than a random person on a wine board, otherwise the price has to be really compelling. Even then,I would not buy without talking to him/her.

[BlaineRyanHunt]

Tom Reddick, Mark G—thank you for seeing where I’m coming from and providing great comments.

Everyone else—thank you for being Berserkers and busting my balls a bit.

[Ed_Gonzales]

Tom Reddick, Mark G—thank you for seeing where I’m coming from and providing great comments.

Everyone else—thank you for being Berserkers and busting my balls a bit.

blaine gets it.

[Mark_Thompson]

This somehow turned into a great thread. Kudos to all.