Dinner with 2008 Cristal, Edge Hill Chard, a Williams Selyem Pinot and Dutton Pinot, all tasted blind

Our Monday night dinner group met recently at Ca Dario Montecito for another excellent evening of fine Italian food, great wines tasted blind and profound fellowship.

Our wine theme was for 1 champagne, 1 white Sonoma County wine and 2 Sonoma County Pinots.

Here’s some tasting notes:

2008 LOUIS ROEDERER CRISTAL BRUT-- blind and poured under the table by the gracious one who brought it to keep it blind; 60% Chardonnay, 40% Pinot Noir; the color was a light yellow; the nose was redolent of citrus fruit with a hint of spice; there was enough stuff to suggest this was a pretty serious bubbly which was confirmed, once tasted; my initial impression got this as being big, rich, highly acidic and powerful and I immediately thought of 2008 as the vintage that epitomized such and I first called it a Taittinger Comtes; the taste profile had a brilliant dose of lemon zest, but a different follow through with dried lime and maybe some licorice coming in at the end; that’s not Comtes; I went through some other possibilities of other 2008s such as Dom Perignon, Laurent-Perrier, Krug and Bollinger Grand Annee, but none really fit this as much as Cristal which is where I eventually landed without certainty; regardless, this was just fabulous and even more ready than most of the previous bottles I’ve had.

2012 EDGE HILL BACIGALUPI VINEYARD RUSSIAN RIVER VALEY CHARDONNAY- blind; this had a yellow gold color and significant aromatics of flint and mildly expressed minerality that was mindful of some white Burgundy; citrus fruit, especially lemon and orange peel was most prevalent in the taste profile along with accents of licorice and coconut, the latter I’m assuming coming from oak influence; initially, it was discombobulated, but in time, everything came together in perfect balance and it was a wonderful wine.

Edge Hill has undergone numerous changes in size and ownership over the years. The winery was built in 1867 and ceased production in 1907. The original estate property consisted of 1500 acres and was portioned off and sold in smaller parcels. Louis P Martine, son of Louis M Martini who founded the Martini Winery, bought the winery in 1952 before selling it to Leslie Rudd in 2000. Rudd then sold in early 2022 (the brand, the property and existing inventory) to Joel Gott of Gott Wines in Napa. The first Edge Hill vintage produced under Gott’s ownership was from 2022 and was produced at Gotts Winery on Hoffman Lane (south of Yountville and the former Havens Winery property).

2011 WILLIAMS SELYEM EAST SIDE ROAD NEIGHBORS RUSSIAN RIVER VALLEY PINOT NOIR- blind, my bring, decanted 2 hours, 1 of 2 Pinots and I did not recognize it; the color was a dark red purple; the nose offered marvelous aromas of spicy strawberry that was joined by red cherry and jujube on the palate; it was fruit forward but not too far from center; it had a soft and smooth mouthfeel and a pleasant finish; I liked it and yet was surprised to find it was the one I brought as I expected more complexity and better balance.

2013 DUTTON ESTATE MANZANA VINEYARD DUTTON RANCH RUSSIAN RIVER VALLEY PINOT NOIR- blind; following its red purple color came aromas of ripe and fresh black cherry/ berry, black raspberry and plum which went all the way to the back end on the palate; this was a youthful and pretty wine with promises for even more pleasure down the line.

This vineyard is located in the heart of Green Valley and was planted in Goldridge soil to “828” and 115 in 2001. 100% de-stemmed, cold soak, aged 10 months in 100% French oak barrels, 33% new.

Dutton Ranch was founded in 1964 by noted Sonoma County viticulturist Warren Dutton. Today, Dutton Ranch farms 1300 acres of grapes that include over 65 vineyards, and 250 acres of apples. Grapes are sold to over sixty wineries, many of which feature the prestigious Dutton Ranch designation on the label.

We had another wondrous evening initiated by a wondrous champagne that rocked big time and it’s still on my palate days later.

Cheers,
Blake

thumbnail_IMG_8871

2 Likes