Dead or Alive? A wine dinner idea

To Brian’s reference, yeah we have done this premise 3 times now. Most recent was here at the house a year ago. Not a dinner, but was an afternoon thing and we had some food brought in for people to munch on. The requirements were few. One was more of an encouragement, which was bring as many shi##y bottles as you wished, but at least one good/great bottle. Another was that it was all blind. Everything was bagged and numbered, and then set in random position on my dining room table, which then allowed people to move about the perimeter to taste and spit, and vote with the stickers. Here are a few photos…




2 Likes

I’ve done this before with some friends. We called it “expired wine night”

1 Like

I think the displayed stickers could lead to some bias. I would prefer to put the red/green sticker on a numbered chit and then stick it in a concealed ballet box

1 Like

One of my friends organized this type of gathering in 2000 when an auction lot he won of Burgundy from the '20s and '30s (that had been imported back in the day through Texas, with fills 1/4 to halfway down) arrived and he wanted Guinea pigs to share the experience. We each brought a wine we all thought suspect and the bait he provided was good bottles of 1959 Coulee de Serrant- Savennieres Doux and a '55 Taylor’s Port. There was actually one Burgundy from 1934 with an awful fill that was really good, but I forget the name. One of the most memorable wines we had was a 1982 California wine made from mission grapes that smelled and tasted just like that '70s and '80s toy Super Elastic Bubble Plastic.

1 Like

Bring out your dead.

There are always some surprises.

Anyone know where I can find a bottle of this?

1 Like

:rofl: :rofl:

That joke hit close to home…as Orange, VA is 45 minutes from where I grew up!

Valid. But also, you might be surprised at the color mix some wines get!! At least with the usual crowd at Frank’s gatherings, people have a nice sense of self-confidence, while also being devoid of pomposity; these folks are not so easily swayed! And that’s the best kind of group to taste with, regardless of tasting setting or type. :blush:

1 Like

We did this same theme as a Halloween tasting, which worked out rather nicely. Never laughed harder during a wine tasting. The “winner” was a KJ chardonnay that had th color of muddy water and smelled like a hockey player’s bag of dirty clothes.

And perhaps a thunder bucket also…

1 Like

Doctor friend of mine that I worked with for years, who is also a gourmet chef and compulsive wine buyer, had a “cellar culling dinner” twice a year…Rich and I wd go through his cellar, pick some wines that I thought wd be DOA as well as few that wd probably be winners…The food and company were terrific, the nights were fun , and some of the suspect wines turned out to be quite nice tho most of the candidates were indeed DOA…His recent holiday card arrived the other day with a reminder that it was time for another cellar culling dinner…good times, good people,good food…the wines are secondary…He has continued to buy more wine than he can possibly drink tho I must admit that his new wine callar is quite an improvement over the previous one

1 Like