Craft or Colicchio & Sons?

What say you?

A recent dinner at Craft was uniformly excellent – food, wine, service.

I would have to go with this…but with the caveat that my experiences are at Craft Steak in Vegas.

i don’t think they’re comparable. depends on whether you want the craft style of creating your own meal or you want proper/composed entrees and appetizers. i would say that if you’re a deuce, then do C&S, but if you’re a 4-top, then Craft could be more fun as you’d get to try more things.

To me, the food at Craft is better but I always end up choosing C&S because its close to my old 'hood and I know the folks there. Although you won’t go wrong with either, IMHO neither is “on fire” (pun intended) compared to some of the competition.

Thanks for the thoughts - going with Craft. All these years up here and I’ve never been.