CLONYC 45 Fairchild Wines with Larry Fairchild

P1030487.jpg
Last night the CLONYC gang hosted Larry Fairchild and an amazing selection from both his current offerings and personal library. It was CLONYC 45 and we did it big-- my fellow CLONYCers have come to expect nothing less. I have been looking forward to this for some time now.

3 flights, 10 wines, lots to say, so let’s get at it…

Flight 1
2010 Fairchild Sigaro- pretty nose of wonderful black fruits. Palate shows a very refined and focused wine with dark currants, blackberries and coffee bean. A light note of cedar brings dimension, Balance is impeccable. As it sits the nose actually gets darker and the wine becomes plusher with a super interesting note of tobacco leaf. I also find a hint of minerality/earthiness in there as well. What an amazing start. My WOTF

2011 Fairchild Sigaro- A bit redder in nose and palate. A nice red cassis driven wine with some sassafras. I get an almost medicinal note on this. Balance is tremendous and finish long. A great effort in a trying year, even above the fog line.

2011 Fairchild GIII- Bolder and darker with some added depth. More blackberries and dark fruited and a similar mout-feel to the Sigaro. Balance near perfect. I think this to be a bit more four-square in style than the Sigaro just as Chris Maybach’s Amoenus is to the Materium. Very nice wine indeed.

Flight 2
2006 Fairchild Sigaro- This opens in the what has become obvious on the night, a Sigaro style: a very fragrant nose of super black fruits. Palate shows some of the coffee-bean and tobacco albeit much quieter and resolved into the soul of this wine. Style-wise, it leans a bit more to the restrained. As usual, balance deft and finish long and true. A pretty good way to start this flight.

2007 Fairchild GIII- So, after just discussing how myself and this group has not found much love in 2007 Napa Cabs, this comes along to stick its multi-layered shoe into my over-opinionated mouth, sideways. Pretty nose of spring flowers and cola with some worn leather and lead pencil shavings. (Something we start seeing more of across the board). This is stupendous with layer upon layer of resolved goodness with no rough edges to be seen, anywhere. It’s delicate in its approach and flinty in its memory. May be one of the top 4-5 2007sm I have ever had, and that is saying much. Wow. My WOTF

2008 Fairchild Sigaro- Whenever I get to sample anyone’s 2008, I always get this rambunctious rascally wine with a tremendous will to just wreak a fun loving havoc on your senses; this wine could be leader of the pack. It’s dark and brash with a playful wistfulness. Its deep, it’s dark it’s multi-layered and it has some cola, some un-cola, some forest floor, some rubbed leather, some tar and lead pencil and some lightning and thunder. Its everything to everyone and yet something you just quite can apprehend, like a bank robber, it wears a mask. Wowsa, wines from 2008 are constantly evolving in a cyclical maelstrom of vortexed conundrums. :slight_smile:

2009 Fairchild GIII- dark fruited with a nice lilty creaminess running right through it. The usual fine grained tannins layered within a very balanced structured boneset. The nose shows a wonderful violet note. The finish it true and long. We had an interesting conversation about GIIIs distinctiveness or lack thereof. What the hell do you mean, Mike? I mean GIIIs can be good, but ‘we’ in this modest group after sampling a nice selection just can’t find any common thread like you would in say a Tokalon or a Dr Crane. Larry agreed and added the vineyard is a bit tricky and just makes great wine. I can’t argue with that because they are….great. This actually reminds me a bit of a well made ToKalon of the now-gone Karl Lawrence.
P1030498.jpg
Flight 3
2012 Fairchild GIII (unreleased)- This one shows tremendously with a more side-ways explosion of the fruits to the Sigaros fully rounded. I also get the redder styled fruit profile. It’s finely woven and densely packed. Hints of cola and cardamom with fresh leather and a slight note of vanilla. A great wine that will astound for many many years.


2012 Fairchild Sigaro (unreleased)- Here is where the rubber leaves the road. This wine is all you could ever expect from Sigaro in a wonderful vintage; skills have been honed and lessons learned all for this very moment where the perfect expression of Sigaro is released upon the world (Next year, lol). I had this as my first taste right after opening; it showed an intensity and structure you would expect from the perfect storm I mentioned above; it’s super deep with a crazy amount of layers and each layer almost seems to hold another variation on the same theme: awesome fruit, lovingly nurtured and delivered to perfection. Larry should put bubble wrap around the cases that hold these bottles, it’s that good. Black cassis driven fruits profile with hints of cola, graphite, leather, cedar-box and exotic tea leaf. Tannins are what you would expect them to be, somewhat large but nowhere can I sense a rough edge. It’s a finely woven wine which has texture and states it presence like a King. As the second to last wine on the night it has become more boisterous or ‘slutty’ if you will, but remains my WOTF and my WOTF. 7 others agreed with me. A wine worthy of the splurge, if you so must.


2011 Stones One- the latest creation of Fairchild, this is adorned with hand made and applied labels that are striking in themselves. This comes from the Las Piedras vineyard. What was once a Syrah laden tract is now reclaimed for Cabernet Sauvignon. I love the concept of this wine. Nose of red/black fruits with tremendous depth and structure. Late in the night but I can still discern it’s greatness. It certainly reminded me of the earlier sampled 2011s with a twist on the fruit profile, with an additional dose of verve and elegance. This shows purity and an interesting sense of place. One to watch.

It was interesting to see the change from the Paul Hobbs made wines to the Philippe Melka. Having tracked Melka wines for many years now, I can say that I believe he has found his place and firmly so with wines like Fairchild; give a talented winemaker some incredible fruit and allow him to do his thing. Everyone seems to win here, especially us.

Thanks to Larry for the opportunity to sample such an amazing lineup of wines. He has both knowledge and passion; he speaks of his life-work almost as a life-pleasure and his magnetic personality just makes you want to shut up and listen. The shutting up part has gotten a bit hard for me to do lately.

Awesome night.
P1030508xxx.jpg

Damn. Jelly. Ive had them all but the 12s. Couldnt agree more with your sentiments so now I cant wait for the 12s.

Mike,

Undoubtedly, it’s good to be the king… [wow.gif]

A great night Mike. Thanks for the invite as always.

An interesting, though expensive, take-away I had on the night was that each Sigaro poured really won me over. I did not appreciate how consistent those wines were until I looked at my notes today. With my affinity for George III juice, this was a welcome surprise.

The wine rankings from the group for each flight were as follows:

Flight #1:

  1. 2010 Sigaro (6 first place votes, 24 pts overall) – my WOTF
  2. 2011 George III (3 first place votes, 22 pts overall)
  3. 2011 Sigaro (2 first place votes, 19 pts overall)

A great start to the night. I fully expected to vote my George III bias and on the nose, the 2011 G3 came out swinging. But over time, the '10 Sigaro really began to shine and won the day for me. It was a wine whose depth and complexity increased as it was savored. Soft, simply fruits gave way to deeper, richer, darker fruits given any amount of time. A wine to be shared with more developed and patient pallets. Definitely not a wine to be shared with family … if yours are like mine!

Flight #2:

  1. 2008 Sigaro (4 First place votes, 35 pts overall) – my WOTF
  2. 2007 George III (4 first place votes, 29 pts overall)
  3. 2009 George III (2 first place votes, 24 pts overall)
  4. 2006 Sigaro (1 first place vote, 22 pts overall)

A rare four wine flight that temporarily threw the official scorer for a loop (sorry!). Don’t let the rankings fool you, this was a strong flight from top to bottom. The rankings tell a tale of 2 flights as the 2008 Sigaro and 2007 G3 stood out among the group but the '06 Sigaro and '09 G3 were both excellent. The fact that nearly half the group had the '08 Sigaro as their 2nd place wine (versus only 1 second place vote for the '07 G3) is what separated it in the final scoring. The surprise for me was the “last” place finish for the '06 Sigaro. I battled back-and-forth with this as my 2nd place wine. The '07 G3 nose was fragrant, playing into my bias, but the savory dark rich fruits on the '06 ultimately won the tie breaker for my 2nd place vote.

Flight #3:

  1. 2012 Sigaro (7 first place votes, 26 pts overall) – my WOTF
  2. 2012 George III (1 first place vote, 20 pts overall)
  3. 2011 Stones (3 first place votes, 19 pts overall)

This flight definitely closed the night with a bang. Even with the unabashed shilling for the '12 Sigaro from the Poobah ahead of the pours, it really lived up to its billing. For me, it was a closer call than most for WOTF as both 2012s were singing from the start. It may have helped that they also had the most time in the bottle/decanter post-popping but undoubtedly the majority of the crowd was positively disposed to the 2012s. In addition to their first place votes, the 2012 G3 received 7 2nd place votes and the 2012 Sigaro received 2 2nd place votes. A wine definitely worth revisiting was the 2011 Stones. Matched against its younger sisters may have been a bit unfair (as 2012 yields were more accommodating than 2011) but the structure and dark fruits on the Stones make it a wine with great aging potential and a high ceiling at maturity. Unlike the Poobah, I like my wines aged a bit so tastes may vary but the quality craftsmanship is undeniable.

All in all, another memorable night of great food, incredible wines and even better company.

Cheers!
Kevin

Nice job, Kevin. Thanks!

*minor detail is the '12 GIII came before the Sigaro, but the scoring is still correct.

Yes Mike, to be clear my order on each flight is their respective rankings, not the order in which they were poured.

oh, my mistake. thanks!

NYC ballas! I got to visit Fairchild.

This CLONYC offered a rare opportunity to compare winemakers. It was fun to evaluate the fruits of the labors of Hobbs and Melka. I expected the Hobbs made wines to be bigger, more opulent, but the opposite was true.
It is a blessing to be able to taste so many wonderful wines at one sitting. Mix in Larry’s detailed candid commentary and the spirited company and my cup runneth over . . .

Again,I read in envy.
Thanks for sharing. Larry is a fellow Nebraskan, so I have a fondness for the wines.

Awesome. Where’s the “Like” button…

Mike and team do it right. I’ve enjoyed the few Fairchild wines I’ve had, will search a few out. Thanks for the notes.

Wow, how cool.

The 2007 GIII was a stunner every time I’ve had it.

What great tasting. Thanks for the detailed notes. I’ve had most of the vintages and was able to taste a few of these the week prior during our visit with Larry in Napa. For the record my favorite G3 is the 2007 and my favorite Sigaro is the 08 with the 10 right behind it. I’d give the 08 Sigaro a slight nudge over the 07 G3.

It does seem like Philip is taking the wines up just a notch in terms of power and ripeness. The 12 Sigaro was a beast when we tasted it as it was straight pop n pour and did not have time to wake up. Our group is hoping we can convince Larry to make a trip in March to Florida for a wine dinner and some golf.

Nice job CLONYC !

Thanks, Fred.
I had the '12 Sigaro on pop’n’pour about 6pm and then as part of the lineup about 830.
I really liked it on PnP. If nothing elses, I am consistent on the young’uns. I am one of those people who very rarely have issue with such young and freshly opened wines. Gift or curse, it’s all me.

It’s a rare bird that gets my attention these days, especially at such a pricepoint, but this is on my radar for next year’s buy if I am so lucky to be given an oppurtunity.

Cheers!

The Prince of Pinot is back!!!

lol.
until tonight…

:slight_smile:

Friday night is Pinot night? [shock.gif]