What I look for but probably not widely available:
St. Cosme CdR or Little James
Pepiere Muscadet
Lapierre Raisins Gaulois
Sartarelli Verdecchio
Any Loire red or white for $15 or less (regardless of label, still probably better than 90% of other $15 or less wines)
Ridge Three Valleys
The Ridge is probably pushing it a bit.
If I had to pick something at a big box supermarket:
Guigal CdR
Jacob’s Creek Shiraz Reserve
Concha y Toro Carmenere, any bottling
Ruffino Chianti
Chateau St. Michelle Cab
J. Lohr Viognier
El Coto Rioja
Imo, AU, Chile and WA really have the supermarket-tier thing nailed, at least for reds…just too much spoof for my tastes from the majority of supermarket CA reds and the French wines at this level are usually dreck (if they even have any). Honorable mention to Spain & Italy, although it’s usually a crapshoot with both in the grocery store.
Is the 2011 a good representation? Got it for $20 around me here. I’m right about to buy it unless you’re about to say, “no - that year was terrible for them” - i’d hate for them to have a bad first impression for me.
C’mon now, this is WB and you knew we were never going to discuss truly “widely available” wines! Hell, I bet some of the supermarket wines in my post aren’t even “widely available” in certain locales…
There are definitely many wines in this thread that don’t seem at all like “everyday widely available stuff,” but I guess those terms are fairly elastic. I could think of things I can find on the shelf at Hi Time and Wine Exchange as being “everyday widely available” in one sense, but I didn’t think that’s what the OP had in mind.