Changing of the guard at Merkelbach

I hoped this day wouldn’t come just yet, but think it’s about the best outcome one could hope for. From the latest Mosel Fine Wines (No.57):

There is some news this year, as the mythical brothers (with well over 100 vintages between them) decided to take a step back. As Johannes Selbach (Weingut Selbach-Oster) explained, “the Selbachs and the Merkelbachs go back a very long way. Alfred and my mother know each other way back from senior high school in Bernkastel. Rolf and Alfred, bachelors, have no relatives nearby and we have enjoyed a very long and very good personal relationship (aside from business). A lot of mutual sympathy and also a lot of business went hand in hand over a long period of time. With lots of mutual sympathy and trust, it also turned out over time that it would be sort of a natural progression if Johannes were to take over not only the chores they could no longer do, but eventually take over the estate from them and to continue their tradition and legacy. When their physical fitness started weakening a few years ago, we gradually started to help them tend their vineyards. In 2020, they asked us if we would and we took over the entire work and we also delivered on the old agreement to take over from them. The wines continue to be made in the brothers’ tradition, in their cellar, in their barrels and it‘s very plain hands-off winemaking, using excellent fruit from mostly old, steep vineyards. The vineyards are excellent (with many old, un-grafted vines in Ürzig) and this makes the difference. Long story short, we will do all we can to keep their legacy alive.” The Selbachs will maintain the Merkelbach Estate completely separate from its own. Also, the wines will continue to be vinified in the Merkelbach cellar in Ürzig.

2 Likes

Knowing the slopes of those vineyards, I’m amazed they were still tending the vines only until a few years ago.

I think this was already the case for the 2019 vintage

Very sad, but agree that this is as good an outcome as possible. Has anyone noticed whether recent vintages of Merkelbach have started tasting more like Selbach wines? I have not had the last few vintages of Merkelbach. Neat that Selbach gets some vines to work in great vineyards new for him.

My first Merkelbach wine was the 2019 Urz Wurz Kabi, so I have no point of reference. Did want to backfill some eventually though, not sure when Selbach started getting involved. Maybe David B knows.

I have some 2018s that I have tried, and they taste like Merkelbach. I have not yet had any of my 2019s to see if there is any difference. That said, if Selbachs are going to use the fuders in the Merkelbach cellars, and use the Merkelbach vineyards I doubt very much that they will taste all that different.

1 Like

And i understood the MFW article to be saying Johannes took over this year, i.e., 2021.

And may I just say, the Merkelbachs could not have made a better selection when choosing to whom to entrust their winery. Johannes is a prince among men.

1 Like

Skurnik’s website indicated that Selbach pretty much handled 2019.

1 Like

Ok

you’re absolutely right about Johannes, though.

I have had Merkelbach from time to time and have some 2018 but have not had anything recently.

When you say “taste like Merkelbach” what precisely does that mean?

TIA

I met Herr Selbach at one of Bob Dentice’s Riesling events. Very pleasant gentleman, but OMG can he drink. As we left the restaurant after who knows how many rieslings, he asks, “Anyone want a beer.” Never wanting to turn down a chat with a winemaker, I stumbled next door and we polished off a pitcher of beer. What kind? Who remembers. What did we talk about? Same answer.

2 Likes

I’m not an expert at all, and I’ve only had 10-20 bottles of Merkelbach, but they almost always have an herbal quality that I’ve heard referred to as sassafras. It’s very interesting, and I haven’t seen that elsewhere. I’ve also heard some people refer to Merkelbach as making riesling at sweetness levels that were traditional in the past, instead of the sweeter style made now. Ie: Their kabinett is true kabinett, whereas other producer’s kabinett is now more at spatlese levels of sweetness. (Yes, I know those are ripeness designations and not sweetness designations, but I’m going to use them interchangeably for now.)

1 Like

FYI - popped a 2019 Kabinett in the fridge. Will open it this evening and report back.

So far the 2019 UW Kabinett tastes like a Merkelbach wine. It’s delicate but has plenty of flavor. Savory/salty underneath the fruit. Going to be fun to follow.