Bordeaux vintage 2025

For those who like B-S-B but cannot bathe in it daily, consider tasting some of the family’s satellite offerings like Roc de Becot or Joanin Becot, from Puisseguin St Em. and Cotes de Castillon respectively. You might have to hunt a little to find them though.

2 Likes

Is Ducru still a peer of Montrose? From the outside looking in, Montrose seems to be separating itself from much of the super second pack (or equivalent)

1 Like

Thanks I agree. I adore the 2019 Rauzan. While I’d prefer it not be the case, I cannot say that the luxury goods owner aspect bothers me as I have been buying Canon (same owner (since the 2020 vintage).

I am really just debating whether it makes sense to buy say, four first growths (2 mouton and 2 haut brion perhaps), or spread that out to other wines.

Clearly that’s the stance the powers at Montrose took. But peer by what measure? Measured by critical scores (with one important exception; William Kelley), they are pretty much peers; any distinction is an exercise in oversubscribing to the effects of small variations.

I sort of get Mark’s pushback. In the recent past, Montrose priced its futures at a slight discount to both Cos and Ducru. You could argue the latter have been overpriced, whereas the former was well-priced. That has informed my own decisions; I haven’t purchased any Ducru or Cos since 2019, whereas I have bought Montrose in relative quantity. However, this year, in a campaign where both Cos and Ducru priced at a significant discount to other recent, well-regarded vintages, Montrose did not. In terms of USD (I haven’t looked at Euro or GBP pricing), it’s actually 20-25% higher than Cos and Ducru. Mark had expressed approbation of Cos’ and Ducru’s aggressive pricing strategy this year. It’s hard to get excited about Montrose’s prices.

3 Likes

Seconded; feel the same way about luxury good owners and being more skeptical there, but the Wertheimers have invested a ton of money into both Rauzan and Canon, which makes me feel a bit better personally.

1 Like

I bought a few from wtso this year. But it looks like they dont currently have it listed. May be worth it to contact them.

Good tip! I’ll reach out. I was looking to get the 2025 futures for my son in a wood case but seems like that may be difficult.

1 Like

That just means that those prior vintages of cos and ducru were way overpriced. You said it yourself, in prior vintages you bought montrose but did not buy cos or ducru. Montrose has been far more restrained in their price increases and decreases so my view is that the 2025 pricing is perfectly reasonable, even if I don’t think EP still makes sense for any of these wines

So I don’t disagree with anything in your post for folks who don’t have a specific reason to buy ‘25 vs. any other vintage. But if youve got a reliable line on ‘16 montrose under $175 or so let me know! Seems to float just under $200 from what I’ve seen? But of course factor in a decade of storage and maybe that isn’t all that bad.

I think people forget that Montrose since 2023 vintage is produced only from so-called Terrasse IV (the best parts of vineyard between the chateau and the river). The new wine Terrasse III, introduced in 2023 vintage, is from vineyard with lesser quality of soil.

I wonder why nobody mentions here one of the best in my opinion wines in the 2025 vintage, Beausejour. Yes, it is 2-2.5 x price of its neighbor, Beau- Sejour Becot, which is by the way an immense value for the money, but Beausejour is something different in terms of purity, finesse and grace. I have followed the work of Josephine Duffau Lagarrosse since I met her for the first time at the property in November 2021, 7 months after she with the financial help of Prisca Courtin- Clarins, succedeed in taking over the property. This woman has a magical touch with her winemaking skills.

I mentioned in one of earlier post, Cantemerle, which made a great 2023 and now an even better 2025. Less than 30 Euros/bottle en primeur 2025, this is a steal.

I will also mention Bourgneuf in Pomerol, the property situated close to Trotanoy. The winemaker, Frederique Vayron, took over winemaking duties from her father in 2008, and didn’t look back with a string of impressive wines. Bourgneuf is a great Pomerol, true to the soil of the district. 60 Euros/bottle.

3 Likes

Turns out it was mostly or all terrace 4 before 2023 too:

It’s not entirely correct. I doubt that 2022 Montrose is 100% Terrasse IV.

Check out this link - FINE+RARE: Talking terraces and terroir with Ch. Montrose

had hoped Montrose would release inline with Cos pricing, the 2025 is a pass for me. Sounds like the chateau releases a relatively small 1st tranche to help drive scarcity and excitement

I’m still waiting to hear back from the Chateau on this.

What does Montrose making the 2025 solely from Terrace 4 translate into? Is the wine different stylistically from prior vintages where T4 composition was less than 100%. Are prior 100pt Montrose from 2010, 2009, 1990 lesser wines because T4 wasn’t absolute. Montrose Marketing Team hard at work

5 Likes

Thanks. Seems like might be a no-go here in the states.

Thank you for your work, this year’s report was valuable and insightful as always. I’m also a big Cantemerle fan. Why do you think others aren’t as loud of an advocate for them? As a chateau it seems to be overlooked and never receives glowing scores even though the wines are delicious and full of class and personality

I think they have been great owners and I have been buying Canon every year on futures since their purchase. They could have increased prices with all of the great ratings from critics like CA wineries but haven’t.

Finally pulled the trigger. 2 Cases total. I went for the following. Very Excited!

Carmes Haut-Brion
Cos d’Estournel
Beau-Sejour Becot
Domaine de Chevalier
Canon
Montrose
Vieux Chateau Certan

3 Likes

Lisa Perrotti gave 2023 Cantemerle 83-85p rating and WA + Vinous underscored it. It’s the same with La Lagune. Wine critics do obviously largely underscore both wines. Jane Anson is the one who loves Cantemerle. I certainly do! think I tasted 2023 Cantemerle 5 times, and the 5th was after bottling, and it was terrific on each occasion. 2025 Cantemerle was made in the new winery and showed more precision, complexity, and length than 2023. If you look at the price, it is simply a steal of the huge ones at 30 Euros!!

1 Like