Yes, it’s hard to generalize given the different grapes used. A wine dominated by carignane won’t resemble a syrah or cabernet, and grenache-heavy blends will have their own taste and style.
On the whole, I think the Southern Rhone is the closest region in terms of texture, and the variety of grapes used.
It’s easy to rage at whatever upcharges KLWM is imposing on certain rarities, but there’s still an ocean of non collectible sub $30 estates they bring in, where - for me - their stamp of approval is enough. I just picked up some Corbieres from them. I’m hoping its not as leathery as ones I remember from years ago…
Totally agree on Gaussac, Barral, L’Aiguliere, and Peyre-Rose. I’d also recommend D’Auphilac, which should be readily available in the US as a Kermit import.
This thread reminds me that I owe a debt of gratitude to Bob Spector on Compuserve’s wine board for introducing me to L’Aiguelière and Peyre Rose. He was a passionate evangelist for the region and his enthusiasm was contagious.
Me too…he and Doug Powers were both fans of a lot of the Sud wines and encouraged me to try those as well as things like Gassac, Mas Champart, d’Aupilhac, etc.