Sheffield’s for American craft with a Midwest focus
Map Room or Hopleaf for a balance tilted a bit more toward Europe
Fountainhead, Bangers & Lace, and Half Acre’s taproom are other favorites of mine
Delilah’s, typically most worthwhile for sipping on whiskey, is having a sour beer event / tap takeover this Sunday afternoon FWIW
Since taps change are frequently changing, you might want to check Beermenus http://www.beermenus.com/
to see if the current list is appealing. The Local Option usually has some excellent beer on tap and a very fairly priced bottle list. Here’s a link to the Local Option tap list: Local Option Bar - Beer Menu - Chicago, IL
I might have to go over there today for a Justin Blabaer. The Local Option is located at 1102 West Webster.
Hopleaf is my personal favorite. Great beer selection, food ranges from great (mussels & frites) to good (everything else), lots of space. Since the American craft beer scene has exploded, the tap list has been leaning more domestic. Map Room is smaller and still emphasizes imports (and import-influenced domestics). They don’t serve food (other than pretzel rods), but The Bristol is walkable from there. I go to Fountainhead a fair bit - it’s in my neighborhood. It has an interesting beer list, but I usually end up getting whiskey. They have a great list.
Sheffield’s and Local Option are also very good, but I don’t go out much in Lincoln Park & Wrigleyville.
Not too far from Hopleaf, Fountainhead at Montrose and Damen has a pretty extensive beer list, and a nice roof deck. The food is better at Hopleaf, but there isn’t as much of a wait at Fountainhead.