It has happened to me, and usually they turn up in an unexpected corner a year or two down the road.
Heck, sometuimes it works the other way. I had two bottles of 2000 Pavie. Last year I decided to put them in the same place. it turned out I had three bottles. When did that happen? 2 months ago, I found a 2003 Marguax in my cellar. I still don’t remember buying that one at all. And it is a 99 point first growth.
And the maddening thing, you’d know if you drank it.
I tore through the cellar twice.
Unless I put it into an old wooden case and closed it up perfectly making it look like an unopened case, which would never happen with my case opening and fastening skills.
So you’re admitting that you’re a “point-chaser” for wines you’ve unexpectedly found in your cellar? [Gasp].
My cellar inventory, ahem, isn’t as up-to-date as it might be. Thus, there are times when I can’t find something I thought I had. But like Matt, it’s usually finding things I didn’t write down yet.
No cleaning lady. I did have some work done in the basement recently adjacent to the wine cellar, but I doubt. I just searched again…they are gone…I could see throwing out a box with one bottle in it but not six, plus, we recycle shipper cardboard.
I don’t lock the doors, ever. Maybe someone came in.