A 'Feast' at El Celler de Can Roca, Girona, Spain

Last month we were going to be fairly close to Girona at the Hotel Mas de Torrent so I emailed the Celler de Can Roca, now No 1 in the world in one set of such rankings, in the faint hope that a table for two might be available and of course it wasn’t but I asked that they contact our hotel if there was a sudden cancellation. To my surprise a phone message was waiting for us when we arrived and on 11th September, Catalunya’s National Day, we found ourselves lunching at a packed El Celler.

We were warmly welcomed and asked if we wished to see the kitchen before the meal which we did and were shown around the very modern kitchen with its several creation, preparation, cooking and ‘assembly’ areas with their teams as well as some of the high-tech gadgets used e.g. to extract and intensify the essence of key ingredients.
The kitchen was full of chefs including several foreigners like Mike from Edinburgh who had been there for two years and an Argentine who is a joint Chef de Cuisine under Joan Roca.
After the meal we were shown around their incredible cellar containing major quantities of the best wines from all over the world. I noticed that e.g. Petrus, DRC etc etc were placed on the highest shelves. For extra wine storage they apparently still use the cellar at their parents’ original restaurant close by which is still operating and is hugely popular with Mama Roca still in charge.
The Roca brothers used this cellar as their first restaurant [hence the name of the new one] before they relocated to their impressive purpose-built building constructed around an old Spanish mansion which Joan Roca lives in and which also houses the new kitchens on the ground floor.

Two fixed menus only were offered and we greedily chose the larger of the two and, more rationally since the whole table must have the same menu, because Susan has become allergic to foie gras and the ‘Feast’ menu contained none.

The menu chosen is given to every customer in their language and the photographs that follow will be in that order although we were actually given the bonbon laden bonsai olive tree first and ‘the World’ second. For no reason we could divine the menu was divided in two and began with 6 ‘starters’ or ‘amuses’ which I have labelled A-G on the menu for ease of reference.

Since I was driving and Susan basically only drinks certain still and sparkling white wines we had to forego the special glass by glass selection to accompany each course. Instead we chose a Cava Gran Reserva Manel Raventos 02 Brut Nature as a replacement to accompany the entire meal while complimentary glasses of Cava were served prior to the meal.
The ‘main’ tasting dishes [1-14] followed.

As the menu shows [A] ‘The World’ was a selection of ‘tastes’ from 5 countries that Joan Roca had recently visited: Mexico, Peru, China, Morocco and Korea and was presented inside a folding paper globe with the world printed on it

**The caramelised olive with anchovy bonbons hung on a Bonsai Olive tree – only one left on ours before I hauled the camera out.

I apologise for the size of the phtographs which have not appeared so large from Photobucket in the past and will limit them to 8 in this post
but will include other dishes from the menu in further posts if people are interested.
The essence of this extraordinary meal was of presentation and intensity of flavour and often colour and I hope these adequately illustrate the presentational and colour aspects.

[1] Boring as a vegetable stock based plate might sound it was delicious and rather beautiful

[3] The white asparagus and truffle viennetta was a perfect blend of intensity and texture in its key ingredients

And the [5] Salad of sea anemone, razor clam, royal cucumber and seaweed in escabeche was as delicious as it was somewhat strange.

Susan couldn’t eat hers [the mackerel also defeated her] so I had both twice. The former grew on me to the point of genuine enjoyment. The latter was a simply an intense and attractive presentation of a fish I like.
So I will skip to two of the desserts [all 3 were magnificent]

[12] The sourdough ice cream with cocoa pulp, fried lychee and sherry vinegar macaro was so tasty although I am not sure why the description doesn’t mention what we assumed, by taste and texture, were tiny meringues covering the outside.

And the jewel-like [13] ‘A fragrance adapted’ with its symphony of blood orange, vanilla, mango and roses

It was a most interesting and enjoyable experience and I hope I have managed to convey some of that here. I apologise again for the size of the photographs but would be happy to provide any of the other courses if anyone wishes to see them.

We were there at 13:00 for 13:30 and finally left at 16:45 after coffee and more bonbons. The roads were eerily empty and we soon discovered why. I had forgotten that on this particular National Day [which our Spanish waiter quaintly described as a celebration of losing a battle – the Bourbons taking Barcelona] there would be a joining of hands the entire length of Catalunya. After many circuits as we were turned back by the police from the crowds watching and forming the line which passed through Girona, we finally found a way to the motorway and made a large circle back to an exit which passed above the line.**

Looks fantastic.

It seems like the menu has expanded considerably in the last few years. When we went 2 years ago I think there was a choice between 5, 7, and 9 courses. A great experience, and Josep’s tour of the wine cellar was neat.

Surprisingly even when it was #4 on the Peligrino list when we visited in 2011, it was not hard at all to get a table. An email about 6 weeks before gave us our chosen time. I guess times have changed!

So did you think it was ‘best in the world’ level food? Ate there a few years ago and liked it, but top 10 in the world? I at least didn’t think so.

Interesting question. I certainly thought each dish was superb in terms of the raw materials, the cooking, the presentation and the way it was served so in that sense I certainly thought it was at ‘best of world’ level but the lack of choice, perversely in view of the variety covered by 24 components, and the inability to have more [because of the naturally small portions] of particular dishes that were particularly delightful does subtract somewhat in terms of a pure eating experience.

Although as I child and young adult I lived all over the world most of my ‘serious’ food experiences in the last 30-40 years have been in Europe at many great restaurants primarily in France, Spain, Italy and the UK and we will usually go a la carte for 3 favourite dishes [starter, main, dessert] with the occasional cheese course added. We almost never have a tasting menu even at the top places and wine is an important part of the meal. The cellar at El Celler was superb but even if one didn’t or couldn’t drink as excitingly as is possible there was good value choice across the board as well as the greatest of wines.

The Feast menu was 190 Euros each but there are higher-priced menus in other 3* Michelin restaurants. The smaller menu was 150 Euros.

Here the choice was limited to two ‘fixed for the whole table’ menus: the Feast and the other somewhat smaller but similar offering which of course does not provide an opportunity to optimise on one’s particular likes and dislikes. As I mentioned, my wife really couldn’t eat two of the dishes which means for optimum enjoyment one needs the most catholic of tastes which I am lucky [or does my waist say otherwise?] to have. Since the dishes were necessarily fairly small I was happy to deal with her rejects.

So: world class? I would unhesitatingly say ‘yes’. Did we both enjoy the overall experience? Absolutely. Would it be something we would seek out frequently? No for reasons I hope I have adequately explained which aren’t anything to do with the skill and content of the food as cooked, presented and served.

The place was absolutely full and everybody seemed to be having a good time with a real buzz in the air.

I have added photographs of another 5 of the courses:
No.4 Mackerel with pickles and mullet roe. Mackerel sauce with white wine, lemon, capers and chillies in vinegar, fried tomato and mullet roe mackerel marinated in sugar and salt. Mackerel infusion.


No. 7 ‘Palo Cortado-steamed langoustine, bisque veloute and Jerez caramel’ tasted just as described with purity of flavour being the key feature of this ensemble. This was one of several dishes where I would have liked to drink their matched wine but the quite Bollinger-like Gran Reserva Cava really did pretty well throughout despite the huge range of flavours.


No.8 ‘Grilled sole with black and white garlic, parsley juice and lemon’ was a perfect piece of sole with a crisp piece of skin [something which has apparently become a fashionable dish on its own in London]. Unfortunately my poorly taken photograph hardly reveals the black and white garlic on the far side of the sole which had been assembled in a thin patterned block.



No.9 ‘Cod with miso and hazelnuts’ reminded me that good cod is a really splendid bite of food. The accompaniment was interesting and well matched and provided textural interest as well as flavour. The only foam on view for that meal although I have no dislike of a properly made and delivered foam – just a suspicion that too much/many sometimes has negative connotations.


No.14 ‘Viola: A sphere if cinnamon and viola with coconut and honey toffee’. I am not sure why ice cream isn’t mentioned in the menu because it was certainly present in this elegant and super-tasting dessert.