A disappointing 2000 Pontet Canet

The TN’s on CT are all over the map. I had to agree with one by London Life; this was a “brooding teenager that has failed to mature”. There were no tertiary notes. No forest floor, not even a brown leaf. A little astringent. Dusty tannins are still present, but I’m not sure the fruit has the depth or strength to follow them to maturity. This was my first of six bottles purchased on release, and I have to decide whether to auction them or risk holding for 5-10.

Cheers,
Warren
IMG_0073.jpeg

Interesting note and question. I have been asking many of the same questions about the 2000’s in general, but specifically Pauillac. Recent tasting of Grande Puy Lacoste raised the same head scratching quandary. I vote hold but not confident in my answer!

That perfectly describes a 2000 Potensac I opened on Tuesday. I was thinking maybe reverse osmosis was to blame for the coarseness. No secondary notes on the nose, no real fruit even though it wasn’t tired. Just a wine with arrested development. And I’m not optimistic it will improve.

1 Like

I’m holding my 00s. Calon and cantenac brown recently were wonderful tho.

I agree with you, Warren. I will be trying my second bottle from a case soon. The first time was slo ox for 24 hours, so this time I will decant and hope for the best…

Cheers,
JP

This has been to some extent my experience with many of the 2000. Various people have suggested that they still need more time, but we are sitting at 20 years. Actually, with the 2000 Pontet Canet, there was a period at 8-10 years where one had the impression that the Merlot in the wine was coming around, since it was expressive in the style of a Merlot (plum and such). Perhaps the Cabernet component is slow??

I am hoping the 2000s are more likely to open up at 24-25 years. I just can’t make myself believe that wines like this and a few other 2000s I’ve tried will just fade away after showing pretty well so young.
Here’s been my trajectory for this wine, from a relatively cold cellar:
2004 - huge and backwards, of course
2010 - backwards again, but very impressive in a primary way
2014 - some hints of secondary development on top of pretty large scale blue fruit
2016 - starting to get pretty interesting

Warren -

Do you generally like Pontet Canet?

I am more often than not totally underwhelmed by this Chateau.

I’ve been drinking a lot of 2000 Pomerol, most of which have been gorgeous.

1 Like

…but I’m not sure the fruit has the depth or strength to follow them to maturity.<

But I´m quite sure indeed. That´s the state many top-Bx 2000 are in now - esoecially right-banker - you would have to sell most of them if you lack enough patience.
Imo 2000 never was an early maturing vintage … except some minor crus I leave alone most of my bottles for a while.

This might be a foolish question, but does anyone see similarities between the 2000’s and the 95’s in their development, or lack thereof?

I didn’t know that RO was permitted in Bordeaux, learning something new every day… [scratch.gif]

I have yet to find the forest floor, brown leaf thing in 95s/96s/98s classified Bordeaux. I just started getting them in some of those terrific 89s/90s
I’ve come to accept that it does take a loooooong time for good Bordeaux to get to the secondary, tertiary mode. But when they do, they do well, very well.

I opened one just last week that was badly corked.

At least your bottle had a valid excuse for disappointing! [snort.gif]

Cheers,
Warren

FIFY. Not an excuse. Sorry for your loss. :slight_smile:

Leoville-las-Cases was an early adopter.

I visited Bordeaux in 2001 and was amazed how many people were open about using it, even in a ripe year like 2000.

Note: In Bordeaux, it’s used to concentrate the wine, while in California it’s more often used to reduce alcohol, I believe.
[Clarified that the visit was to the region and now LLC/Potensac.]

1 Like

My only note apart from Primeur was from five years ago, when it was very closed, but I thought I detected some good stuff behind it. Your note is a little disappointing, as I have a couple of bottles left.

I’ve got three bottles of Pontet Canet 2000, purchased back in 2003, and haven’t tried one yet. It was promising back in 2003 after having just been bottled. I recalled how tannic it was, lots of structure. Could it be a closed phase? I recall trying Montrose 2000 back in 2012, and it was truly closed. Haven’t tried a 2000 Montrose ever since.

I think Warren had a bad bottle. I’ve noticed some bottle variation or cork issues with P-C in this vintage, based on my case which I bought on release and stored properly.

I disagree about this being like 1985 where there was a race to see if the acid/tannins would outlive the fruit. This is just not a Bordeaux made in a classic Bordeaux style. I believe this will end up being more of a new world style when it comes around. It needs a lot of air at this point.

Here’s my notes from a bottle I opened last night for our brown bag tasting group:

  • 2000 Château Pontet-Canet > - France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac (5/29/2021)
    From a case bought on release and stored cold, in the low-50s. Double decanted four hours before tasting.

Very dark, opaque red with no color loss on the rim. Still has lots of tannins and acid, but the acid smoothened out considerably in the glass over 20 minutes. Black fruits, cassis coming out.

I think this wine is still too young and needs more time to come together, but it’s getting there. There is some bottle variation or cork issues with this vintage based on other tasting notes. > __

Posted from > CellarTracker

Drinking now 2nd bottle from a case. Much better this time! Balanced…with a long finish. Cork was perfect and I am happy; 2 hour decant to be matched with grilled meats.

Cheers,
JP