Okay, I remember reading Cris Whetstone say something to the effect “Andy drinks more port in a month than I will in my lifetime”. Well, sipping these cask samples over 2 days, I can easily say I have had more Port in the last 3 days than I have had in my lifetime. Here’s the set: these were open 4 days prior to Traci and I trying them (Andy has been following them since day 1). First day blind so we got to discuss them before unveiling. I took my notes on my night number 2 (day 5 of being open). You can take these with a grain of salt since I have ZERO experience with vintage port cask samples. My notes will be in order of the wines tasted.
2007 Quinto do Noval - nose shows a little grapey with nice cassis fruit, stone, flowers/orange blossom and a little violet. The palate is rich and dense with toffee, chocolate, more cassis and chewy tannins and high acidity. Given the tannin and acid profile, along with the density of fruit, I would believe this should age well. 93++
2007 Romaneira - never heard of this property before (doesn’t say much though). Nose shows a little more simple than the Noval. Chocolate, cassis and blackberry. On the palate a little mushroom compote, underbrush, milk chocolate with rich fruit but a trace of heat at the back end. Good enough acid that this should drink well in the near to mid term…basically drink this 5-15 years out while you wait for the likes of Noval, Sandeman, etc., to start to come around. 88-91
2007 Quevado - another I hadn’t heard about. The nose is the least expressive of the samples showing a little earth and blackfruit. On the palate, some heat, wet stone, high acid with some nice but somewhat subdued dark rich fruit. If the fruit holds up and the acid subsides this could be a little sleeper of a wine. 88-91
2007 Sandeman - this was awesome. Nose is rich black fruit, plum, toffee and fig while the palate boasts big chewy tannins and amazing acidity cloaking tremendous tar, mint, fig and black fruit. I gotta believe this is something that should easily age 30-40+ years and be awesome…if I were a Port buying man, I’d load up on this. 95-97pts
2007 Fonseca - very disappointing and apparently this is consistent with 2 other cask samples my bro has had. Simple nose with some plum and a fairly simple experience on the palate as well…hmmm…did something go wrong here?