Aged Cali Cab

[John Danza]

'84 and '87 are highly underrated vintages, and worth seeking out for all the names listed above - the '87 Montelena is still one of my all time favorite Cabs with a little bottle age -

I grab 1984 vintage whenever I can get them at a decent price, since it's the year my wife and I were married. I even ran into a Maryland Cabernet from the 1984 vintage and it was still "ok" (barely) 10 years ago.

[Andrew A r n t f i e l d]

Cali Cab from the mid to late 80s that I've opened in the past 3-4 years and that has been more than superb:

Beaulieu GDL
Beringer Private Reserve
Burgess Vintage Selection
Diamond Creek Volcanic Hill, Gravelly Meadow
Dunn (both HM and Napa)
Heitz Martha's
Ridge Monte Bello
Spottswoode

[JDavisRoby]

I have a 2001 Forman Cab I intend on opening tonight. Been standing up for a couple days now. Any recommendations on decant time? This will be the oldest Forman I’ve opened by about five years.

[Ed Steinway]

Thomas Keim wrote:
'84 and '87 are highly underrated vintages, and worth seeking out for all the names listed above - the '87 Montelena is still one of my all time favorite Cabs with a little bottle age -

Both are excellent vintages for California Cabernet. The 1984 Ridge Monte Bello we had a few years ago was one of the best bottles of wine I have been fortunate enough to drink.

Ed

[Brian Lynch]

Recently drank a ‘59 Charles Krug at Press in St. Helena that someone purchased off their list and sent over to the table for me as a gift. It was the wine of the night, a real feat considering we had an ‘89 Haut-Briton and several other treasures sitting on the table. What struck me the most was how youthful it seemed. Really thrilling stuff.

It could have been the MacDonald fruit

[Mich@el Ch@ng]

75 Charles Krug at Berns was nice.

[John Danza]

75 Charles Krug at Berns was nice.

I had a 1979 Charles Krug Zinfandel at Berns a couple of years ago that cost $29 for the bottle. It was outstanding and nowhere near over the hill. I know it's not a Cab, but it shows the ability for these older wines to stay the course over time.

[Howard Cooper]

75 Charles Krug at Berns was nice.

I had a 1979 Charles Krug Zinfandel at Berns a couple of years ago that cost $29 for the bottle. It was outstanding and nowhere near over the hill. I know it's not a Cab, but it shows the ability for these older wines to stay the course over time.

I had a 1978 Ridge Geyserville a couple of years ago that also was fabulous.

[Anton D]

I think we are entering the age where more and more people discover the splendid beauty of aged Cali cabs.

Great thread.

[Lee Braem]

Just drank a bottle of Michel-Schlumberger Reserve 92. Good cork, color still on red side, adequate fruit and great nose. A very good bottle of wine.

[Andy Sc]

75 Charles Krug at Berns was nice.

I had a 1979 Charles Krug Zinfandel at Berns a couple of years ago that cost $29 for the bottle. It was outstanding and nowhere near over the hill. I know it's not a Cab, but it shows the ability for these older wines to stay the course over time.

I had a 1978 Ridge Geyserville a couple of years ago that also was fabulous.

I can second that. I've found the 1972 Geyserville on a restaurant list last year and it was singing. The head sommelier (of a 3 star restaurant) mistook it for a 20y+ old high-end Richebourg.

[Mark Golodetz]

I have been part of several old Zinfandel tastings, and frankly the percentage of disappointments was incredibly high. The only two consistent producers were Ridge and Joseph Swan.

[Dennis Atick]

I had a 1979 Charles Krug Zinfandel at Berns a couple of years ago that cost $29 for the bottle. It was outstanding and nowhere near over the hill. I know it's not a Cab, but it shows the ability for these older wines to stay the course over time.

I had a 1978 Ridge Geyserville a couple of years ago that also was fabulous.

I can second that. I've found the 1972 Geyserville on a restaurant list last year and it was singing. The head sommelier (of a 3 star restaurant) mistook it for a 20y+ old high-end Richebourg.

Ridge Zins from the mid-70s served blind were the best wines of my most recent Berns trips in '16 and '18. Amidst some serious competition.

[Howard Cooper]

I have been part of several old Zinfandel tastings, and frankly the percentage of disappointments was incredibly high. The only two consistent producers were Ridge and Joseph Swan.

Frankly, the only Zins I drink are from Ridge (at any age), although I would like to try Swan.

[Howard Cooper]

I think we are entering the age where more and more people discover the splendid beauty of aged Cali cabs.

Great thread.

I hope that this is not happening at a time when some classic producers (like Phelps) who made wines for a long time that aged very well have moved to the dark side.

[Howard Cooper]

I have a 2001 Forman Cab I intend on opening tonight. Been standing up for a couple days now. Any recommendations on decant time? This will be the oldest Forman I’ve opened by about five years.

How was the wine?

[Mel Knox]

As I recall the old C Krug Vintage Selects were based on fruit from the See Ranch, now part of Silverado

[JDavisRoby]

I have a 2001 Forman Cab I intend on opening tonight. Been standing up for a couple days now. Any recommendations on decant time? This will be the oldest Forman I’ve opened by about five years.

How was the wine?

It was great! The dusty, cassis and tobacco nose and complex texture I love on older Bordeaux varietals. But, still enough fruit up front and acid in the mid palate which I believe says it had lots of life left. Cork was in great shape.

Opened a 2014 Angelus No 3 after. What a huge difference!

[Victor Hong]

The early-1990s stuff has really disappeared from auction and retailer sites. Note the observation in Commerce Corner.
viewtopic.php?f=7&t=169982

I wonder why.

[John Danza]

The early-1990s stuff has really disappeared from auction and retailer sites. Note the observation in Commerce Corner.
viewtopic.php?f=7&t=169982

I wonder why.

My go-to for this stuff is typically Winebid. There seems to be a decent number of lots available this week.

[NED VALOIS]

'74/'78 Mondavi Reserve !

[Glenn L e v i n e]

Just a joyous bottle which made up for some duds on the actual birthday.

This wine had real energy, both sweet & tart fruit easily appreciated, length without bitterness. Tannins resolved but not completely absent yet. Delicious bottle.

[Dave McIsaac]

Just a joyous bottle which made up for some duds on the actual birthday.

This wine had real energy, both sweet & tart fruit easily appreciated, length without bitterness. Tannins resolved but not completely absent yet. Delicious bottle.

A3C8C12C-7AE7-4CB6-9F30-C7C260671F4A.jpeg

Birth year wine, G??

[William Anzalone]

Last nights RIDGE Monte Bello with Age Roundtable featured the 1990, 2001 and 2002. This event has been talked about in another chat but below I attached a link to the 1990 bottle 375 ml that can be purchased directly from Ridge. Its expensive but in-line with the 1 and only 1990 bottle found on Wine Searcher. Since the event was last night, I believe this bottle will only be available for a very brief time. It was for sale for last night's event but its still on the website. Its $190 and if you are a member of any of the Ridges programs you get 10% off ($171). There is also free 2 day shipping.

I drank the 1990 last night and it was a beautiful wine.

https://shop.ridgewine.com/shopping_car ... 375ml.aspx

[Glenn L e v i n e]

Just a joyous bottle which made up for some duds on the actual birthday.

This wine had real energy, both sweet & tart fruit easily appreciated, length without bitterness. Tannins resolved but not completely absent yet. Delicious bottle.

A3C8C12C-7AE7-4CB6-9F30-C7C260671F4A.jpeg

Birth year wine, G??

1/2 way.

[AD Northup]

Thomas Keim wrote:
'84 and '87 are highly underrated vintages, and worth seeking out for all the names listed above - the '87 Montelena is still one of my all time favorite Cabs with a little bottle age -

Both are excellent vintages for California Cabernet. The 1984 Ridge Monte Bello we had a few years ago was one of the best bottles of wine I have been fortunate enough to drink.

Ed

Been absolutely loading up on these two vintages this year as they are my wife and my birth years. Will start popping them open in June over the next few decades, but appreciative of all the positive notes.

[Br1an Th0rne]

I buy the ‘92 Togni whenever I see it at a decent price...for me, Togni is one of the few CA Cabs that evolves and significantly improves and develops complexity with age. And the ‘92 is at the top of that short list.

[T. Altmayer]

I have had some good luck recently at auction with aged Cal Cab. Picked up early to mid 90s Whitehall Lane which has been lovely. Also has some Staglin and Merryvale profile from the late 90s that has really exceeded expectations. All bought on Winebid and not a bad bottle yet.

[Glenn L e v i n e]

84-87 are the greatest four year run in CA history.

Underrated?

[Scott Jameson]

84-87 are the greatest four year run in CA history.

Underrated?

I might argue with "greatest" but these years are definitely in the discussion, and are far from "underrated".

[Glenn L e v i n e]

Exactly. 91-94 as good perhaps.

[S. Stevenson]

84-87 are the greatest four year run in CA history.

Underrated?

'67 to '70 was better.

[Glenn L e v i n e]

No way. The case can be made for 91-94 but not those four vintages.

[Mike Maguire]

I would include 95 to the 91-94, so really stellar ones that are still drinking great.

[Marek Hnatyk]

I would include 95 to the 91-94, so really stellar ones that are still drinking great.

I would also add 97, all wines I had from this vintages were at least outstanding or great ( Newton , Ahlgren, Diamond Creek VH, Forman, Staglin). I also read many good opionions on www.cellartracker.com about Napa cabernets from 1996 so in fact vintages 1991-1997 would be the greatest period for Northern California Cabernet Sauvignon.

[Mark Golodetz]

I buy the ‘92 Togni whenever I see it at a decent price...for me, Togni is one of the few CA Cabs that evolves and significantly improves and develops complexity with age. And the ‘92 is at the top of that short list.

A man of rare taste and intelligence.

[Mark Golodetz]

Depends on the type of wine you like. Very few wines post 1990 that I have found developing the interesting stuff I look for in aged wine.

[Marek Hnatyk]

I buy the ‘92 Togni whenever I see it at a decent price...for me, Togni is one of the few CA Cabs that evolves and significantly improves and develops complexity with age. And the ‘92 is at the top of that short list.

A man of rare taste and intelligence.

I had almost 2 years ago Togni 94, very nice wine however without "wow" factor which I hoped for.

[Br1an Th0rne]

I buy the ‘92 Togni whenever I see it at a decent price...for me, Togni is one of the few CA Cabs that evolves and significantly improves and develops complexity with age. And the ‘92 is at the top of that short list.

A man of rare taste and intelligence.

Clearly a case of great minds thinking alike