I will be in Tribeca mid week with my wife (Chambers Street Wines and other essentials) and would be grateful for recommendations for a restaurant for lunch.
I have not been to Augustine but given it is a Keith McNally restaurant his stick is usually to do watered down versions of French Bistros. Pete Wells gave it a ho hum 1 star review.
Frenchette has elevated classic french cooking and although it is a style I rarely go for I think the food is excellent. For comparison Pete Wells gave it a glowing 3 star review which is unheard of for a casual restaurant.
I only point this out because you said you picked Augustine over Frenchette because you don’t want French food.
I would be curious to know if anyone has eaten at both Augustine and Frenchette and how they compare.
They’ve talked about lunch ever since they first opened. I didn’t think they had done it but since they subscribe to the far too common school of horrible restaurant website design it’s easy to find bios of their chef and somm but impossible to find their hours.
I think I am the only one here that had a crappy dinner at Frenchette, but my frites were a salt lick, the duck breast was tough, they knocked over chairs passing my table and they seemed to be a little too pleased with themselves. (and that was before the *** review) Dinner was so bad I won’t brave the crowds to give it another shot despite seeing so many good reports.
I would add Del Posto for a great $59 lunch in the area as well as Batard and Locanda Verde.
I would second Locanda Verde and Del Posto, haven’t been to the others. In Soho nearby there is Balthazar, which probably has one of the best steak frites. Also good selection of french wines
My recent meal at Frenchette was good. I would say the food was exactly what I expected. Well executed bistro food. The service was excellent and the people watching was even better. Overall a fun and enjoyable experience, but if you’re going to France shortly, I wouldn’t bother. I do like the Locanda Verde suggestion.
Markus Glocker of Batard is now heading up the kitchen at Augustine so I would disregard any prior reviews. I have not been since he took over but I would be pretty confident that you would eat very well there.
For the wine list, Tribeca Grill is a standout–food not so much. Locanda Verde good, not great in my opinion, and the vibe is a little too relaxed and crowded.
OK so I had lunch at Augustine which was perfectly fine for what I wanted and in exactly the right location for my meeting. On Monday Amy and i had dinner at Racines which was very good. Enjoyed a bottle of 2015 Tissot La Mailloches with our food and could see myself going back regularly just for the wine list! Thanks to all for your advice.