Page 11 of 12

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 13th, 2020, 2:16 pm
by Randy Bowman
Revisiting the Oliva V. Barnyard on the foot and powdered cocoa on the cold draw. Started out with pepper and coffee notes again. After smoking a third of it, I'm getting some nuttiness and cocoa. The room note of the smoke is cocoa and the Iwater I'm drinking tastes like chocolate. At two thirds, there is vanilla and all spice notes. The flavors are smooth and fairly light. The cigar is smoking about medium, so my tastebuds are probably still lacking.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 14th, 2020, 3:13 pm
by Jesse Koehn
Roma Craft Baka

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 14th, 2020, 3:13 pm
by Jesse Koehn
And a Viaje Super Shot 10 gauge

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 17th, 2020, 9:54 pm
by Jason Hagen
Hey all! I'm back. I enjoyed catching up on what is being smoked.

Southern Draw Kudzu Robusto
Another excellent smoke from Southern Draw. Easy to smoke with great richness. Not too complex but downright tasty. Happy to have more in the humi. Sweet spice and chocolate. Nice finish. = A

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 18th, 2020, 6:35 pm
by Jason Hagen
On lockdown but have these on deck.
AVE MARIA IMMACULATA TORO, GUARDIAN OF THE FARM CAMPEON, CROWNED HEADS LUMINOSA TORO, PADRON 1964 ANNIVERSARY CORONA, CROWNED HEADS J.D. HOWARD RESERVE HR48, EP CARRILLO NEW WAVE CONNECTICUT DIVINOS

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 18th, 2020, 7:09 pm
by Randy Bowman
Nice looking assortment. That Kudzu looks like it would be in my wheelhouse.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 18th, 2020, 7:18 pm
by Phil Smith
Still too cold here but the self-isolation is a positive pressure to get outside and smoke. I ordered a couple of boxes of small cigars (Padron Corticos, Fuente Hemingway Short Story) to pass the time just in case the weather doesn't cooperate.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 18th, 2020, 7:22 pm
by Randy Bowman
Wish I could ship you better weather. We are finally having some rain.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 18th, 2020, 7:34 pm
by Phil Smith
Thanks Randy... the sentiment is appreciated either way.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 19th, 2020, 2:00 pm
by Jason Hagen
Going out during breaks in the rain.

Alec Bradley Black Market Esteli Robusto 5X52
Not sure if this is just AB inconsistency or the Robusto just doesn't hold up to the Torpedo but this cigar was just okay. Some pleasant flavors but the draw was pretty tough even after hitting it with the Perfect Draw. = C+

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 19th, 2020, 5:01 pm
by Jason Hagen
Ave Maria Immaculata Toro $3.20 Purchased Feb. 2020

Right when I sat down it started raining ..booo. But it cleared quickly. Still tough to believe this cigar is made by AJ. A very nice mild cigar. Easy smoking. Dry flavors of wood, nuts and about halfway through some white pepper comes in. Not a head turner but a great mellow cigar. 80 minute smoke.

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 19th, 2020, 8:12 pm
by Randy Bowman
Jason, you had problems with the AB Esteli robusto being nothing like the torpedo and I don't have the answer but maybe a thought. For me, the Oliva V Torpedo was killer, yet the robusto was questionable, twice and the draw was a little tough. Doubt it is different tobacco, but possibly who rolled it in your case and maybe mine. I Cuban cut the torpedo, twisting and turning it to hit all the taste buds with a perfect burn. Couldn't coax the flavors from the robustos no matter what I tried and they didn't seem to have the same flavor profile either. I blamed my taste buds, but maybe we were victimized by the "apprentice" roller.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 19th, 2020, 10:12 pm
by Jason Hagen
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 19th, 2020, 8:12 pm
Jason, you had problems with the AB Esteli robusto being nothing like the torpedo and I don't have the answer but maybe a thought. For me, the Oliva V Torpedo was killer, yet the robusto was questionable, twice and the draw was a little tough. Doubt it is different tobacco, but possibly who rolled it in your case and maybe mine. I Cuban cut the torpedo, twisting and turning it to hit all the taste buds with a perfect burn. Couldn't coax the flavors from the robustos no matter what I tried and they didn't seem to have the same flavor profile either. I blamed my taste buds, but maybe we were victimized by the "apprentice" roller.
Thanks for the insight. I'll try another Robusto in a few weeks. Thankfully I still have more of the Torpedos.

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 20th, 2020, 6:49 pm
by Jason Hagen
The first day on full California quarantine so I sat outside and did some recovery reading.

Guardian of the Farm Campeon by Warped $5.99
What a terrific cigar which is always expected from Warped. Upon lighting the aromas were fantastic. Rich medium/full cigar. Chocolate Latte, nuts and a bit of earthiness. With the final third of the cigar, the flavors got a little more muddled and white pepper became a distinct flavor. Perfect draw and burn. 110 minute smoke. = A+

Crowned Heads J.D. Howard Reserve HR48 $5.15
Round 2 for today. A great 45 minute smoke. Medium profile but still packs some power and is an easy smoke. Spicy with a bit of sweet chocolate and leather. Smoked to the nub for sure. = A

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 21st, 2020, 3:02 pm
by Randy Bowman
Hunkered down in the cigar lounge with a My Father La Opulencia and a bottle of water. Both are excellent.
20200321_145914.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 21st, 2020, 5:34 pm
by Jason Hagen
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 21st, 2020, 3:02 pm
Hunkered down in the cigar lounge with a My Father La Opulencia and a bottle of water. Both are excellent.
Nice. I have wanted to smoke one of those.

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 21st, 2020, 7:43 pm
by Randy Bowman
Jason Hagen wrote:
March 21st, 2020, 5:34 pm
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 21st, 2020, 3:02 pm
Hunkered down in the cigar lounge with a My Father La Opulencia and a bottle of water. Both are excellent.
Nice. I have wanted to smoke one of those.

J
Good luck getting that water lit. neener

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 22nd, 2020, 5:58 am
by Jud Reis
Had a lovely H Upmann Banker Toro yesterday walking the beach with friends - amazing how cigar smoke helps enforce social distancing! Crisp sunny day was lovely to have a smoke and a conversation in the midst of all this craziness.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 22nd, 2020, 5:05 pm
by Jason Hagen
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 21st, 2020, 7:43 pm
Jason Hagen wrote:
March 21st, 2020, 5:34 pm
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 21st, 2020, 3:02 pm
Hunkered down in the cigar lounge with a My Father La Opulencia and a bottle of water. Both are excellent.
Nice. I have wanted to smoke one of those.

J
Good luck getting that water lit. neener
There was a time when I smoke with water .... a lot [wow.gif]

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 22nd, 2020, 5:05 pm
by Jason Hagen
Jud Reis wrote:
March 22nd, 2020, 5:58 am
Had a lovely H Upmann Banker Toro yesterday walking the beach with friends - amazing how cigar smoke helps enforce social distancing! Crisp sunny day was lovely to have a smoke and a conversation in the midst of all this craziness.
Sounds perfect.

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 23rd, 2020, 10:34 pm
by Jason Hagen
EP Carrillo New Wave Connecticut Divinos
$2.85 - Very enjoyable. On the mild side with a touch of kick. Toasty and earthy but not overly dry flavors. Great morning smoke when you have the time. There were tiny sections where the draw was a bit vacant but with a few strong puffs is was back to a mouthful. = B+

Romeo y Julieta 1875 Bully
A decent smoke. Somewhat simple and boring. Around 2/3s it was more intriguing but still nothing special. = C+

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 24th, 2020, 5:27 pm
by Randy Bowman
Nat Sherman Timeless Supreme Robusto

Tea aromas/flavors on the foot/cold draw. Mild and creamy with ever changing flavors including cedar, roasted nuts, tea, earth, coffee bean, cocoa, berries and light spices. Palate pleaser end to end.
20200324_165444.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 25th, 2020, 2:54 pm
by Randy Bowman
Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro Robusto

A Maduro lover's delight. Lots of coffee and chocolate that appear in various forms like espresso, coffee bean, bittersweet and milk chocolate as well as in combination, mocha. White pepper on the finish. Occasional hints of cream, sweet berries and earth.
20200325_142834.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 25th, 2020, 4:09 pm
by Mike Maguire
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 25th, 2020, 2:54 pm
Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro Robusto

A Maduro lover's delight. Lots of coffee and chocolate that appear in various forms like espresso, coffee bean, bittersweet and milk chocolate as well as in combination, mocha. White pepper on the finish. Occasional hints of cream, sweet berries and earth.
20200325_142834.jpg
Not a cigar smoker but love your passion!

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 25th, 2020, 7:49 pm
by Randy Bowman
Mike Maguire wrote:
March 25th, 2020, 4:09 pm
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 25th, 2020, 2:54 pm
Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro Robusto

A Maduro lover's delight. Lots of coffee and chocolate that appear in various forms like espresso, coffee bean, bittersweet and milk chocolate as well as in combination, mocha. White pepper on the finish. Occasional hints of cream, sweet berries and earth.
20200325_142834.jpg
Not a cigar smoker but love your passion!
Funny thing is I was a cigar smoker and wine drinker for a lot of years before joining WB. Started posting notes on wines and realized I wasn't knowledgeable, just a wine drinker until I had to actually describe what I was drinking. It was a whole new approach to consumption and perception. It actually changed my palate and range of wines I enjoy. When they started this thread, I stopped smoking cigars and started tasting cigars. Again, my palate and range changed as did my enjoyment. I not longer drink my favorite wine nor smoke my favorite cigar. An old dog learned a new trick.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 26th, 2020, 2:36 pm
by Randy Bowman
A. Fuente 858 Claro

Looking at the green wrapper I'm thinking it will taste like grass or bell pepper. Can't detect much on the foot or cold draw. The cigar is mild and creamy. Sweet cedar is the dominant flavor with occasional nuttiness and a fleeting hint of mint on the finish. Swishing water over my tongue produces a sweet light mint flavor that lingers to the next draw on the cigar. Two thirds of the way through, the sweetness is waning, with mild spices appearing. Impeccable construction, burn and draw. Not complex but an interesting departure from my usual choice in cigars.
20200326_135306.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 27th, 2020, 1:55 pm
by Jason Hagen
Sounds fun. I have never had one of them green wrappers. Can't decide if I find them attractive or ugly.

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 27th, 2020, 2:05 pm
by Jason Hagen
Montecristo Platinum Toro
The last time I had this cigar it was pretty much fresh off the truck and the burn was uneven and jacked up. With a little rest in the humi this has straightened out. The draw is still a bit tough but I hit it with The Perfect Draw and it was fine. Nice bold full-bodied flavors. Unsweet cherry, espresso, and some leather. A small amount of spice. In your face but not very rich. = B

Kristoff San Andres Robusto
A bouncing baby bruiser. Lot's of flavor. Cinnamon, hot chocolate and leather. All a bit disjointed right now but an attention getter. It was a bit hotter than I prefer. The draw was a bit uneven. Sometimes great, sometimes hard. It will be a while before I smoke another. = B+

Alec Bradley Black Market Vandal the Con Toro
I had one of these about 5 weeks ago and it was just a bit of a pain to smoke. This was better but there were still problems with the burn. Nice mild cigar. Flavors a pretty dry with a touch of cream. = B-

Southern Draw Firethorn Toro
I really like Southern Draw. After a few months in the humi this is really coming together. I am hoping the balance increases. There are flavors of espresso and chocolate which are accompanied by green chili at the front and red chili in the mid palate. The green chili brings some acidity and the red chili brings richness. About have way through the smoke I did some popsicle stick. Not great. But that passed. Very enjoyable, somewhat easy smoking med/full cigar. = A-

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 27th, 2020, 2:53 pm
by Randy Bowman
Fuente Don Carlos Personal Reserve Robusto
20200327_134418.jpg
Rich tobacco notes on the foot and cold draw. Starts out with cedar and black pepper. There is a citrus component that is building between the cedar and black pepper as it nears the second third. At half way the cedar is fading and being replaced by notes of earth and mild kitchen spices. The citrus component is gone by the start of the final third, replaced by caramel, leaving some sweetness on the finish. All the flavors intensify as I reach the end of the cigar. Stellar.
20200327_141413.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 28th, 2020, 10:13 am
by Jason Hagen
Nice. One of my all-time favorites. But I don't have those fancy Corona gloves. Thanks for the note.

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 28th, 2020, 10:16 am
by Jason Hagen
Lockdown Mail Call! -
Aladino (Corojo Reserva)
Guardian of the Farm (Claude de Chien - Made by Kyle from Warped)
Casdagli Traditional (formerly Bespoke Cigars but had to change their name thanks to Alec Bradley)
Warped (Flor del Valle)
Warped (Serie Gran Reserva 1988)
Casa Fernandez (Miami from 2012)
PG (Gourmet Series - Rolled in 2001)
PSyKo SEVEN

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 28th, 2020, 2:28 pm
by Jason Hagen
Macanudo Icon Robusto
A nice satisfying smoke. The only drawback was as the flavors became more intense and complex, the cigar also got hot. Creamy and woodsy. = B+

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 28th, 2020, 2:46 pm
by Randy Bowman
Padron Damaso #8 Corona

Been in the humidor for at least three years. Leather on the foot. Rich tobacco on the cold draw. Starts out with sweet cedar, leather on the mid and black pepper finish. Ash is a little loose and drops easily. The second third is sweet cream, mild spices, leather and the black pepper finish. The cigar has gained strength to medium for the final third. Some cedar notes have returned and the spices have intensified. The burn is perfectly even end to end. Tasty and mild.
20200328_140352.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 29th, 2020, 3:09 pm
by Randy Bowman
God of Fire 10th Anniversario 5.5 x 60 Figurado

Smooth best describes this cigar. Rich yet creamy. Leather, almonds, earth, baking spices and mild pepper are core flavors. A hint of cocoa here and there. Sweet caramel also comes and goes adding to the complexity of the cigar. A little red pepper appears on the finish at the end of the cigar. Awesome.
20200329_140523.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 29th, 2020, 7:34 pm
by Jason Hagen
Comfortably Numb Vol. 2 By Espinosa
I enjoyed this much more than Vol. 1. Full flavor but not overpowering. Meaty and peppery with some dark chocolate. = A-

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 30th, 2020, 2:43 pm
by Randy Bowman
Oliva V Melanio Robusto

I remember this cigar as full bodied with a pepper edge but today it is medium and smooth. Leather with some woodiness and light on the pepper. Occasional notes of toast and caramel. Midway through, a fleeting citrus note appears on the finish. Winding down, toast is more prominent, citrus gone and caramel provides sweetness on the finish. Even better than I remember.
20200330_141001.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 30th, 2020, 4:21 pm
by GregP
Randy, and Jason. Been watching a number of reviews in the past 3 weeks, and some of them do not make sense to me o cigars I know really well. Oliva V, to my palate, is only rivaled by Davidoff Winston Churchill and Yamasa. And yet... My boxes are all from stock of 2-4 years ago and deliver great flavors, no exceptions. So, curious to know when yours were acquired, just want to understand if the issues are with recent releases, or not. If there is a way to post approximate date of cigars when you post reviews that would really help (same as wine vintage, I guess). I have had sub-par experience with recent releases of a number of once great lines that now taste crappy. Not really a surprise when labels change hands and production numbers increase dramatically to capitalize on name recognition. And greed, I guess.

Oliva is different, still private and still same AFAIK. Tasted Oliva V Melanio next to Oilva V a good number of times and always prefer the V. And now curious what gives with the above reviews. Not critical, just trying to understand if I should keep on buying at this point, or look for something else. Still have 4 boxes of Vs, and will now ration them, or rather, research well before re-stocking.

TIA.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 30th, 2020, 6:10 pm
by Jason Hagen
Diesel Whiskey Row Robusto
I am generally a Diesel fan but this .... hmmm. The cigar did smoke fine and the construction was solid. Flavors start off with nothing exciting. It showed wood and some elements of Bourbon but lacked any elements of sweetness that the new oak brings to Bourbon. One dimensional. Later there was some dark chocolate but still no complexity. I have a few others but I will be in no hurry to smoke them. Maybe time will bring them together. = D

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 30th, 2020, 6:35 pm
by Randy Bowman
GregP wrote:
March 30th, 2020, 4:21 pm
Randy, and Jason. Been watching a number of reviews in the past 3 weeks, and some of them do not make sense to me o cigars I know really well. Oliva V, to my palate, is only rivaled by Davidoff Winston Churchill and Yamasa. And yet... My boxes are all from stock of 2-4 years ago and deliver great flavors, no exceptions. So, curious to know when yours were acquired, just want to understand if the issues are with recent releases, or not. If there is a way to post approximate date of cigars when you post reviews that would really help (same as wine vintage, I guess). I have had sub-par experience with recent releases of a number of once great lines that now taste crappy. Not really a surprise when labels change hands and production numbers increase dramatically to capitalize on name recognition. And greed, I guess.

Oliva is different, still private and still same AFAIK. Tasted Oliva V Melanio next to Oilva V a good number of times and always prefer the V. And now curious what gives with the above reviews. Not critical, just trying to understand if I should keep on buying at this point, or look for something else. Still have 4 boxes of Vs, and will now ration them, or rather, research well before re-stocking.

TIA.

Greg,

In 2016, Oliva Cigar Co. was acquired by J. Cortez Cigars N.V., a Belgian tobacco company that wanted a premium cigar operation in its portfolio.

Most of the cigars I post on have been in the store's humidor between 30 minutes and three months. Cigars that are real popular sell faster and I'm continually ordering them. There are a number of cigars that languish, either because they are too expensive or not getting ratings. The older ones I always try to estimate how long I've had them. Right now I have three different Fuente Anejos that have been in the humidor for three to five years.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 30th, 2020, 11:26 pm
by GregP
Randy Bowman wrote:
March 30th, 2020, 6:35 pm
Greg,

In 2016, Oliva Cigar Co. was acquired by J. Cortez Cigars N.V., a Belgian tobacco company that wanted a premium cigar operation in its portfolio.

Most of the cigars I post on have been in the store's humidor between 30 minutes and three months. Cigars that are real popular sell faster and I'm continually ordering them. There are a number of cigars that languish, either because they are too expensive or not getting ratings. The older ones I always try to estimate how long I've had them. Right now I have three different Fuente Anejos that have been in the humidor for three to five years.
Randy, thanks for the info. Looks like still "family owned" and run, same factory, same tobacco fields. And yet, sounds like Cortez may have requested a bump in production numbers and that may have altered a few things. Need to buy a few lose Vs and smoke them next to my stash to see what's different. I know that Liga Privada was a great marketing bait and switch, and there are others. What made them make a splash, originally, was then replaced by a huge bump in production and definitely different tobacco (same as buying fruit from a 4 acre vineyard vineyard in Napa and them switching to one that 100 cares, just different animals). Hoping that Oilvas did not follow the script, and judging by your take on Melanio I really cannot explain your experience with the V.

Every time I seem to find a few great sticks and load up I eventually see them go bad, for whatever reason. Shame. But learned to buy, big, once I come across a good cigar.

Find it funny that Fuente Anejos are not selling, they used to be the hottest thing around not that far back. Have no idea what the attraction of the new wave cigar market is, who wants to buy a limited release cigar in full knowledge you can never buy more? That is if you can even find some. And, TBH, I find way too many of them simply overblown marketing crap, expensive and made from subpar tobacco.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 30th, 2020, 11:41 pm
by GregP
Jason Hagen wrote:
March 30th, 2020, 6:10 pm
Diesel Whiskey Row Robusto
I am generally a Diesel fan but this .... hmmm. The cigar did smoke fine and the construction was solid. Flavors start off with nothing exciting. It showed wood and some elements of Bourbon but lacked any elements of sweetness that the new oak brings to Bourbon. One dimensional. Later there was some dark chocolate but still no complexity. I have a few others but I will be in no hurry to smoke them. Maybe time will bring them together. = D

Jason
Funny, you just pretty much described every Diesel cigar I have smoked, starting with when they showed up and people were raving about them :-) Never understood the attraction.

I have yet to come across one Diesel cigar that is not a simple wood and black pepper notes with no other redeeming flavors. You get a hint of something or other, here and there, but just that, a hint, quickly disappearing, with wood and pepper still taking center stage, overwhelmingly. No nuance, no change in flavors. With usually a harsh finish, to boot. Pretty much any other cigar I light up right after tastes like a big step up. And I did light up one right after, almost every time, just to "calibrate" my palate to see if it is the Diesel cigar and not my palate at fault.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: March 31st, 2020, 3:07 pm
by Randy Bowman
God of Fire by Carlito Double Robusto 2015

This cigar has been in the humidor for about one year. Uneven burn at first solved with a little touch up. Pepper drives this stick. Not overpowering but always there. First there were tea notes. They were joined by leather and sweet cedar. Caramel replaced the cedar about mid cigar along with some earthiness. Carrie said the room note is milk chocolate or something that reminds her of the old malted milk balls we ate as children. I don't detect either on the cigar. Various kitchen spices come and go the entire cigar. Pretty complex.
20200331_135830.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 1st, 2020, 2:29 pm
by Randy Bowman
CAO Flathead V554 Camshaft

The cigar has been in our humidor for about five years. Good looking dark brown oily wrapper. Barnyard funk on the foot and some faint chocolate on the cold draw. Starts out with cocoa, some earthiness and white pepper on the finish. Wonderful draw with lots of smoke. Solid ash. Some leather notes and sweet caramel join in by the halfway point. As the cigar winds down, some spice notes, most notably cinnamon, appear just before the the light white pepper finish. Not real complex but very tasty.
20200401_135457.jpg

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 2nd, 2020, 9:07 am
by Jason Hagen
GregP wrote:
March 30th, 2020, 11:41 pm


Funny, you just pretty much described every Diesel cigar I have smoked, starting with when they showed up and people were raving about them :-) Never understood the attraction.

I have yet to come across one Diesel cigar that is not a simple wood and black pepper notes with no other redeeming flavors. You get a hint of something or other, here and there, but just that, a hint, quickly disappearing, with wood and pepper still taking center stage, overwhelmingly. No nuance, no change in flavors. With usually a harsh finish, to boot. Pretty much any other cigar I light up right after tastes like a big step up. And I did light up one right after, almost every time, just to "calibrate" my palate to see if it is the Diesel cigar and not my palate at fault.
I like the Diesel line but would agree they are fairly monolithic although I generally like the flavors I get. At $3-4 all in, they work for me.

I have some Olivas but I have liked over years of trying them. But I have some more that have more humi time and I'll revisit soon. In the humi are a few of the Saison 2009 Harvest but I have never tried one.

Padron and Fuentes are probably my favorite non Cubans the Padrons are too pricey for me to have on a regular basis. I have some Davidoffs but they are way out of my price range. I'd rather get Cubans from Switzerland or sticks from Warped (much cheaper & maybe better).

I am getting more Marrero cigars and will report back. Top 5 cigar of 2020 for me. Had 4 years of humi time.

I am really enjoying Southern Draw (AJ :-) )

Off to smoke an Ortega Cubao.

Jason

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 2nd, 2020, 9:12 am
by Jason Hagen
Caldwell Eastern Standard Sungrown Robusto Purchased Jan. 2020
The draw was easy but was a little vacant and the burn was okay. First quarter of the cigar was fairly interesting. Cinnamon spiced brownies, leather and it took me a while to figure out there was a bit of gooseberry in there. By half way through the smoke it became monolithic. Earth, wood, and pepper. It became less interesting as it went on. The original Eastern Standard is more pleasant. = C

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 2nd, 2020, 2:10 pm
by Jason Hagen
GregP wrote:
March 30th, 2020, 4:21 pm

... Tasted Oliva V Melanio next to Oilva V a good number of times and always prefer the V.

TIA.
I have only had one V to the best of my recollection but have recently gone through a few V Melanio. After my last one, I have decided to let them rest. It did not intrigue me like the first time I smoked one. A bit fatiguing. Have you had the Master Blend 3? I tried one a while back and liked it a lot. Still very big. Letting my others sleep.

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 2nd, 2020, 2:13 pm
by Jason Hagen
Ortega Cubao - Toro
This has really smoothed out with some time in the humidor. Great classic style. No harshness. @$2.89 all in I am very happy to have more Toros and Robustos. = B+

J

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 2nd, 2020, 11:15 pm
by GregP
Jason Hagen wrote:
April 2nd, 2020, 2:10 pm
GregP wrote:
March 30th, 2020, 4:21 pm

... Tasted Oliva V Melanio next to Oilva V a good number of times and always prefer the V.

TIA.
I have only had one V to the best of my recollection but have recently gone through a few V Melanio. After my last one, I have decided to let them rest. It did not intrigue me like the first time I smoked one. A bit fatiguing. Have you had the Master Blend 3? I tried one a while back and liked it a lot. Still very big. Letting my others sleep.

J
Yes, bought a box a while ago. Just an average cigar, IMO. One of those that got a lot of noise, but to my palate not really worth it.

I really like Oliva O, and to some extent G as well.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 2nd, 2020, 11:29 pm
by GregP
Had a friend over for dinner tonight, home made lox, chicken liver pate, slow cooked beef cheeks, lamb shanks with chick peas.

Afterwards Oliva V Robusto with Pappy 15 year old. Seriously good cigar, in all respects.Deep, rich flavors, lots of complexity and nuance, roasted nuts, dark cherry notes, smooth, long and clean finish that makes you reach for another draw. On par with anything out there, IMO.Both of us easily compared it with Davidoff Winston Churchill at a better price point.

This was from a box bought 3+ years ago. Will light up a 15 year old Liga Privada tomorrow.

Re: What Cigar or Pipe Are You Smoking?

Posted: April 3rd, 2020, 12:32 am
by Jason Hagen
Nice.

I have an O Maduro on deck for tomorrow. Not sure what I am going to have with my coffee but it could be that or something on the more mild side.