For my tastes, I would choose from these. I might opt for 2 bottles of Champagne and 1 Vouvray (or vice versa) and 1 bottle of red based on the menu, but it definitely leans towards white wines. The riesling looks to be a good choice for the meat course in place of the red and could possibly be better allowing for an all champagne & white wine dinner.
Charles Heidsieck Brut Reserve Champagne $99
Domaine Huet Clos du Bourg Vouvray Sec $100
Lopez de Heredia Crianza Rioja Tempranillo $80 or Domaine Faiveley Mercurey Rouge $95 or Selbach Oster Riesling Feinherb $65
Pick four wines that you think offer a range of flavors that your friends will appreciate. (You presumably know these people, whereas none of us do.)
Nothing else matters.
The Huet is versatile and well priced vis-a-vis the other options. Would definitely also go with the Heidesick. Cubillo is good and already has some age even if not well priced.
That broccoli is a special dish - make sure to dup plenty on your plate. The Charles Heidsieck would go nicely with the richness of the blue cheese in it.
I’d put the Bernabeleva in the lineup. I really love this producer, and the Camino de Navaherreros is a good intro to the elegant style of old vine garnacha being made in Sierra de Gredos. Very food friendly and will go with most of the menu items, except the hamachi.
Really enjoyed the Girl and the Goat in the past. They have a very solid wine selection and would be surprised if they did not have varietal selections that were spot on in terms of classic pairings. On another note, if you have time and are in town for a few days, I would hit Au Cheval down the street. Best burger I have ever had (multiple times confirm it). Get there early or late or the wait will be long as they do not accept reservations. Get the bacon and the egg on the single (which is a double patty) and be prepared to either be stuffed or to share.
Sorry for the thread devolution, but G&G and Au Cheval bring back great memories.
what are the vintages Dan? I’d tend to take/agree with Markus’ list and then choose from either the Labille or the Selbach Oster if it’s a 19 or 15 e.g.