Interesting side by side.
2018 Scherrer Dry Rose: Beautiful pale salmon color. Strawberry, a hint of oregano, spice and limestone on the nose. Lovely texture, strawberry on the attack with nice bracing acidity.
2018 Tercero Mourvèdre Rose: almost identical salmon color. Definite feral Mourvèdre note on the attack along with some melon fruit and just a hint of white pepper. Thick, viscous texture with nice balancing acidity and just a hint of vanilla bean on the finish. Lovely.
Both wines are very enjoyable, but have to give the Tercero a slight edge as it has just a little more oomph. Two of my favorite winemakers doing great things.