TN: 2013 Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey Saint-Aubin 1er Cru En Remilly

  • 2013 Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey Saint-Aubin 1er Cru En Remilly - France, Burgundy, Côte de Beaune, Saint-Aubin 1er Cru (3/20/2020)
    Popped and poured. The nose is textbook PYCM; minerals, citrus, flint, spice and highly aromatic. Crips, lean and tart palate, good volume paired with copious acidity and a long finish. Outstanding for the village. (91 pts.)

Posted from CellarTracker

Is there a better bargain in Burgundy than a $43 Saint-Aubin from PYCM?

I love to re-read the vintage reports from a producer when I’m drinking a wine that I really like, in the futile hope of discerning patterns that will help to inform future buying decisions. 2013 was a challenging year in Burgundy that taxed the growers. See the writeup below. It’s no surprise that Pierre Yves delivered amazing wines in a difficult year, as he is a conscientious grower to a fault. Bottom line conclusion for me, it all comes down to the old saw: “producer, producer, producer”.

Pierre Yves Colin described the 2013 vintage in one word, “galère,” which basically translates as the vintage from hell. He went on to say that “it was beyond complicated. There were so many aspects to manage and each of them had to be done in exactly the right way and exactly when they had to be done. 2013 was definitely a vintage that tolerated no laxity. One good example is that in May there was strong mildew pressure but it was so wet and muddy from all of the rain that we couldn’t get any machinery into the vineyards. So there was no choice but to treat manually and let me tell you, that is just nasty work. The suits are heavy and hot, the tanks are heavy, there’s 5 pounds of mud clinging to each of your boots while you’re trying to navigate straight up a slippery and very steep row while making sure that you completely treated the foliage for each vine. Worse, we had to do this twice. Honestly, if I never have to do it again it will be too soon.

We picked from the 30th of September to the 4th of October but stopped on the 5th due to the huge rain storm. We resumed picking on the 6th and then harvested through to the 9th. The fruit was surprisingly clean and sugars were reasonably good at between 11 and 12.1%. The skins were thinner than they were in 2012 and we were able to do our normal pressing. Acids though were right at the limit of what I prefer so I decided to block from 10 to 15% of the malo for each wine. In the same spirit I thought that the wines were sufficiently rich that they didn’t need any lees stirring so we did none at all. After all that we went through, I am genuinely shocked at how good the wines are because I honestly never expected this level of quality. The wines are fresher and more terroir than the 2012s though they’re not as dense and powerful. Still, I prefer the style of the 2013s because they make you feel like drinking them and that’s always an encouraging sign for aging potential.”

$43 for a Saint-Aubin from PYCM happened long ago in a galaxy far, far away.

My thoughts exactly, Howard. This wine now runs around $100.

This was purchased 5 years ago, not exactly a long time. And the 2017 was purchased for $55 just last fall.

I had this wine about a month ago and then was fortunate to have dinner with PYCM. I mentioned that I had this and he asked how it was drinking. I told him I thought it was beautiful and he said the last time he tried it he thought it was still a little too tight. So I’m taking this as this wine still not being quite ready in his opinion. Whatever the case it’s really good.

Agreed Jerry, it’s drinking really well at the moment. I’m holding off on popping the 1er crus and grand crus, but the Saint-Aubin wines are on deck.

Wow, we loved this. It’s put on weight (haven’t we all) and viscosity since our last bottle a year and a half ago. Ripe lemon cream, struck match with flinty minerality. Everything is generous, classy and in perfect harmony; the texture, dense fruit, reduction, acidic cut and long finish.
It was mislabeled in the 2014 slot, but I’m happy I pulled this one by mistake.
IMG_0052.jpg

Sounds lovely, thanks for sharing. The 2014 probably wouldn’t have been as accessible, so you lucked out.

It’s not. Opened one a few months ago and it was incredibly tight after 4 hours.

Good to know, thanks.

The best available price for this wine, in any vintage, is $145 accdg to WS. In, what, 3-4 years this has gone from a bargain wine to a truly expensive wine.

All PYCM has, used to buy Ancegnieres for $60, makes me feel like all you old guys reminiscing about the prices of BDX back in the 80s and 90s. [berserker.gif]