Napa and Sonoma Wine Visits, January 2020 – Part 3b (Smith Story, Gros Ventre)

Tasting notes, varietals, grapes - anything related to wine
Post Reply
Message
Author
User avatar
Ken Zinns
GCC Member
GCC Member
Posts: 3627
Joined: March 11th, 2009, 4:53 pm
Location: Oakland, CA

Napa and Sonoma Wine Visits, January 2020 – Part 3b (Smith Story, Gros Ventre)

#1 Post by Ken Zinns » February 12th, 2020, 7:42 am

Napa and Sonoma Wine Visits, January 2020 – Part 3ab

I've posted another portion of Part 3 of a report on an early January three-day wine tour with friends Eric Anderson and Michael Poston to Napa and Sonoma wineries and tasting rooms. The full version of this report is on the Grape-Nutz.com website:
Napa and Sonoma Visits – January 2020 – Part 3

Smith Story Wine Cellars
Gros Ventre Cellars



Smith Story Wine Cellars
After our relaxing lunch, we had two scheduled afternoon wine appointments – conveniently, both were in the same custom crush facility, located barely a stone’s throw from Russian River Brewing. Grand Cru Custom Crush in Windsor is a new and very up-to-date winemaking facility that includes several rooms that can be booked for tastings. We were there to taste the wines of Smith Story Wine Cellars, a fairly new producer with an interesting story – I suppose it’s the Smith Story story! We were welcomed by the winery’s director of hospitality, Will Kinney – we already knew that owners Eric Story and his wife Alison (Ali) Smith Story would not be able to get there until a bit later. Will led us to one of the Grand Cru tasting rooms, a nice space for hosting a small group of visitors – I should mention that in addition to this tasting room, Smith Story has another one located in Philo in Anderson Valley. I’d only met Eric and Ali once before, at a tasting of Anderson Valley wines in 2017, and I was intrigued by both their wines and their story.

73 smith story.jpg
The beginnings of Smith Story Wine Cellars go back to 2003, when both Eric and Ali were working at K&L Wines in San Francisco. Ali is originally from Texas, with a background in radio and television, and she developed the TexaCali Wine Company, a sales and marketing firm for small wineries and importers. After moving to California, she worked in marketing at K&L – Eric also worked there, and he became a buyer, focusing on wines from Germany, Loire, Alsace, Austria, and Greece. It took a few years, but eventually Eric and Ali started dating, and in 2013 they eloped on the Big Island of Hawaii. That same year they launched their winery, and since they had little capital to get it going, they used a Kickstarter campaign to help fund the winery startup – probably the first time that a winery had been crowdfunded. The winery logo features a border of a Hawaiian wedding lei, and the “H” and “L” in the logo stand for the names of their two retrievers, Henley and Lakota, that they had when they met back in 2003.

A key thing to know about Eric and Ali is how much they love dogs, and you’ll rarely see them without their beloved goldendoodle, Lord Sandwich. They’ve made many connections to customers through this, and in fact it was through a goldendoodle connection that Will first got in touch with Eric and Ali. They also started a non-profit program called Socks for Sandwich – not socks for their dog, but for those in need. They’ve had about 40,000 pairs of socks donated to date.

77 smith story.jpg
Eric Story and Lord Sandwich

The first vintage for Smith Story was in 2014, and the winery’s focus is Sauvignon Blanc, Anderson Valley Pinot Noir, and Bordeaux-variety reds. Another focus is that they work only with family farmers – they’re currently working with nine growers, and have worked with as many as 16. Eric makes the wines, while noted Sonoma County vintner Katy Wilson is the consulting winemaker. An interesting part of the Smith Story wine line-up is a pair of wines made in Germany. Eric had worked for a time at a winery there, and through his Eric Story Selections, he now imports a Riesling and a Rosé of Pinot Noir from the Rheingau region exclusively for Smith Story. Total wine production is about 4,000 cases per year, with the Sauvignon Blanc being the largest production at around 1,600 cases. Eric and Ali moved their production to the Grand Cru facility shortly after it opened in 2017. Winemaking is low-intervention, and they don’t add anything other than minimal sulfur.

Will, who’s been working with Smith Story for about 18 months, started us out on tasting a couple of white wines. Fruit for the whites is all sorted and then whole-cluster pressed. The 2018 Sauvignon Blanc was made in stainless steel with fruit sourced from three vineyards in Knights Valley, Sonoma Mountain, and Russian River Valley. Lots of grapefruit and floral aromas, with medium-light weight on the palate, bright acidity, and a fresh finish. Will told us that Sauvignon Blanc was the first variety that Eric and Ali decided they wanted to make when they started their winery. The 2016 Dutton Ranch Chardonnay fruit came from Mill Station Vineyard, a cool, foggy site farmed by Dutton family in western Russian River Valley. The wine was fermented and aged in about 20% new oak, and went partially through malolactic fermentation. This showed pear and spice on the nose, with a hints of lemonpeel and earth, medium-bodied with a lively texture and finish.

It was just about when we finished tasting the Chardonnay that Eric and Ali arrived, along with Lord Sandwich of course. They’re in the middle of moving to Anderson Valley, so it was great that they could spare some time to see us at Grand Cru. We took a break from the tasting room so that Eric and Ali could give us a quick tour of the facility – it looks to be very well set up for custom crush clients.

76 smith story.jpg
Will Kinney and Alison Smith Story

Back at the tasting room, Eric and Ali poured us two Pinot Noirs, both from Anderson Valley. They’d made a few Pinots from Sonoma County fruit in the past, but since 2016 they’ve all been sourced from Anderson Valley. All Pinot fruit is sorted and destemmed at the winery, and the wines are typically aged in about 25% new French oak. First was the 2017 Helluva Vineyard Pinot Noir, from a site next to a creek in the Boonville area that’s shaded from afternoon sun by the nearby mountains. From 100% Pommard clone, this had very light ruby color plus subtle aromas of red fruit, tea leaf, and spice that opened up with more air in the glass, with medium-light body and good structure, finishing with fine tannins. The 2016 Nash Mill Vineyard Pinot Noir has a special connection to Smith Story, as Eric helped plant the vineyard in the Deep End of Anderson Valley in the early 2000s. From Pommard 5, 115, and 667 clones, this was barrel-aged for about 18 months. The wine featured more upfront black cherry and plum fruit than the Helluva bottling along with a floral quality, hints of tea leaf and earth, and a bigger texture on the palate along with more noticeable tannins on the finish.

Our final wine was the 2016 Pickberry Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon, from a site on Sonoma Mountain with vines that are around 25 years old. There’s about 20% Merlot from same vineyard blended in, and the wine was aged in older French oak barrels. Very pure black currant fruit plus spice, herbs, and pepper notes, medium-full bodied with a lively mouthfeel and moderate tannins.

Other Smith Story wines that we didn’t taste during our visit include Thorn Ridge Vineyard Pinot Noir, “The Boonies” Pinot Noir (from Anderson Valley), Merlot, and Cabernet Franc, plus “Lord Sandwich Blanc” and “Lord Sandwich Red” blends. There’s also the Riesling and Rosé of Pinot Noir from Rheingau in Germany. Eric and Ali mentioned that they would like to add a Pinot Blanc to the line-up and hope to find the right vineyard source for that soon.

79 smith story.jpg
Our visit with Eric, Ali, Will – and Lord Sandwich! – was an enjoyable one. They all have outgoing personalities and their enthusiasm about the wines was obvious. The current Smith Story wines seem to find a good balance between being either too ripe or too lean and acidic. All of the wines were nice, and I thought the 2018 Sauvignon Blanc and 2017 Helluva Vineyard Pinot Noir were particular standouts. The 2016 Nash Mill Vineyard Pinot Noir was also quite good, and both Pinots showed a distinct Anderson Valley character. Arranging a visit at Grand Cru in Windsor – or stopping by their regular tasting room in Anderson Valley – will be a fun and worthwhile experience.


Gros Ventre Cellars
The final visit of our three-day Sonoma and Napa wine tour was just a few steps down the hall at the Grand Cru custom crush facility in Windsor, with Chris Pittenger of Gros Ventre Cellars. I’d first met Chris at a West Sonoma Coast wine tasting in 2012 and I felt that the Pinot Noirs that he poured there were among the standout wines of the day. I’ve tasted his wines at other events over the years and visited him a few years ago when he was making his wines in El Dorado County, and I thought this would be a great opportunity to see him again now that he’s returned to Sonoma County.

80 gros ventre.jpg
Chris grew up in Southern California, and he started out working in wine shops and restaurants in Colorado and Wyoming before moving to the production side of wine. He’s been with famed wineries including Robert Biale, Torbreck, Kim Crawford, Williams Selyem, and Marcassin. In 2007, Chris made a move to El Dorado County in the Sierra Foothills to become the winemaker for a new Rhône specialist producer, Skinner Vineyards – Chris’ work there has led them to become one of the most highly-regarded wineries in the region. In 2009, Chris and his wife Sarah launched the Gros Ventre label – the name was inspired by two things. Chris and Sarah first met in 2003 near the Gros Ventre River in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, and later, as they were looking for a name for their label, Sarah was pregnant with their first child – Gros Ventre (French for “big belly”) was Chris’ playful nickname for her during that time. The initial 2009 Gros Ventre wines were made at what’s now the Punchdown Cellars facility in Santa Rosa, while from the following year through 2017 they were made at Skinner. In 2018, Chris left Skinner to take the position of winemaker at Limerick Lane Wines in Russian River Valley, and he moved the Gros Ventre production to Grand Cru that year.

Gros Ventre started out with an exclusive focus on Pinot Noir from the West Sonoma Coast, Russian River Valley, and Anderson Valley, and that’s still a key part of their wine program but no longer the only wines that Chris makes for the label. Starting in 2016, he began to make Gros Ventre wines using some of the vineyard sources he’d become familiar with during his time in El Dorado County, using varieties including Gamay Noir, Vermentino, and Fiano. Chris told us that Gros Ventre started with only 300 cases for their inaugural 2009 vintage, and they’re now making about 1,800 cases per year, with 12 different wines. About 1/3 of the total production is the “High Country Red” blend and another 1/3 consists of the various small-production Pinot Noirs.

82 gros ventre.jpg
Chris Pittenger

Chris works with well-regarded growers who farm their vineyards using sustainable methods, and many of the vineyards are farmed organically or biodynamically. Particularly for the Pinot vineyards, the sites are in cool-climate locations. Chris typically decides how to treat the fruit at the winery once it gets to the crushpad. He doesn’t follow any pre-determined recipes for the wines and makes decisions – including whole-cluster inclusion for reds – based on vintage, vineyard, clone, and other factors. Fruit is fermented using native yeast, and wines are aged in mostly older barrels. Chris mentioned that he doesn’t force white wines to finish malolactic fermentation – some may finish completely and some may not. It’s an advantage for Chris that he works mainly with many small lots of fruit, giving him more flexibility in how he can deal with each individual lot.

We started our tasting with the 2018 Chenin Blanc, from an organically-farmed vineyard in the Merritt Island AVA. Though this particular appellation itself is little-known, it’s part of the larger Clarksburg AVA, one of California’s best-known growing regions for Chenin Blanc. He was introduced to the vineyard through the grower’s son, whom he worked with at Williams Selyem in 2005. Picked at less than 21 brix, this finished at just 12.7% alcohol. The wine displayed green apple and citrus aromas with hints of flowers and spice, medium-light weight with vibrant acidity and a fresh finish. Chris poured us one more white wine, the 2018 “High Country White,” a blend of 28% Grenache Blanc, 24% Picpoul, 24% Chenin Blanc, 21% Vermentino, 2% Fiano, and 1% Arneis mostly from two high-elevation vineyards in El Dorado County plus Chenin Blanc from Clarksburg. Another wine that came in at under 13% alcohol, this was aged in stainless steel and older oak. Citrus combined with stone fruit on the nose, plus notes of flowers and fresh herbs, with a broader mouthfeel than the Chenin Blanc along with fine acidity and a lively finish.

84 gros ventre.jpg
We followed with our first Gros Ventre red, 2018 Gamay Noir, grown in the decomposed granite soil of Barsotti Vineyard, located northeast of Placerville in El Dorado County. Chris said that this has some whole-cluster fermentation and was aged entirely in neutral oak. Wild berry and earth aromas with herbal and stony mineral notes, this had good structure with moderate tannins on the tangy finish. Chris next poured us the 2018 “High Country Red,” a blend of 55% Pinot Noir and 45% Gamay Noir, aged in older barrels. The Gamay comes from Barsotti Vineyard while the Pinot comes from vineyard sites in El Dorado County, Anderson Valley, and the Sonoma Coast. Plum and raspberry fruit plus earth, herbs, and spice on the nose, with medium body and a similar tangy finish to the Gamay Noir.

Chris had four of his Pinot Noir bottlings for us to taste, and he began with the 2017 Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir, with fruit sourced from several vineyards, made entirely from free-run wine, and aged in about 20% new French oak. Lots of upfront spice aromas along with black cherry fruit and undertones of vanilla/oak, medium weight with milder tannins. Next was the 2017 Baranoff Vineyard Pinot Noir, from a site near Sebastopol in heart of Russian River Valley that’s farmed by Paul Sloan of Small Vines Viticulture. It’s a cool and windy site planted in the mid-1990s to seven Pinot clones with high-density 4x3 vine spacing. I thought this was a step up from the first Pinot, with black cherry and plum fruit, tea leaf, orangepeel, and earth on the nose, a more structured mouthfeel, and moderate yet fine tannins on the finish.

85 gros ventre.jpg
Our next wine was the 2017 Campbell Ranch Pinot Noir, from a vineyard at about 750-foot elevation in the Annapolis area of the West Sonoma Coast. Made from 115 and 777 clones, the wine was aged in 25% new French oak. Chris first got fruit from this site in 2011 and he’s been working with it ever since. This wine featured a more savory profile than the first two Pinots, along with focused black cherry and raspberry fruit, tea leaf, and spice, both elegance and structure on the palate, and a firm yet lively finish – delicious already but will benefit from time in the cellar. Our final Gros Ventre wine was the 2017 Cerise Vineyard Pinot Noir, from a hillside site high above Anderson Valley, made from Pommard, 115, and 667 clones, and aged in just 13% new French oak. Chris has worked with this site since his first vintage in 2009 but 2018 will be his last there due to vineyard ownership changes. Wonderful aromatics, showing a distinctly stony mineral quality plus dried herbs, spice, and red fruit, with a taut, structured mouthfeel and firmly tannic finish – this has lots of promise but deserves time to develop further.

I asked Chris what he feels are the main differences between Pinot Noir from the Sonoma Coast and Russian River Valley. He said that Sonoma Coast fruit tends to provide more purity and intensity, while Russian River Valley fruit generally provides a broader texture to the wine. In addition to the appellation and single-vineyard Pinots, Chris also makes a Pinot Noir bottling called “First Born” that’s a blend of select barrels in each vintage. He told us that he’s adding a new Pinot vineyard near Occidental and he’s looking for other potential sites too.

In addition to the wines we tasted with Chris, other Gros Ventre wines include “Alto Paese” (an Italian-style white blend), Vermentino, Fiano, a Pinot/Gamay rosé, El Dorado Pinot Noir, and the “First Born” Pinot Noir. Chris is also planning a future North Coast Pinot Noir bottling that will include fruit from both Sonoma County and Anderson Valley.

We had a good time tasting with Chris – he’s got a very low-key personality that seems to be reflected in his wines. The whites both had terrific acidity while the reds had fine structure and texture – great balance and restraint. Most of the reds showed a nice combination of fruit and savory qualities. The single-vineyard Pinots in particular displayed beautiful aromatics and showed great distinctiveness between the vineyard sources. My favorites of the tasting included the 2018 Chenin Blanc, 2018 Gamay Noir, 2017 Campbell Ranch Pinot Noir, and 2017 Cerise Vineyard Pinot Noir – the two Pinots in particular were standouts. If you haven’t tried the Gros Ventre wines, you owe it to yourself to check them out soon.

83 gros ventre.jpg
ITB, Harrington Wines & Eno Wines, and Grape-Nutz.com

Post Reply

Return to “Wine Talk”