I had a 2011 this past weekend and I thought it was lovely. While clearly new world, definitely made in style reminiscent of the northern rhone, which I like.
Had one of these a few weeks ago. It was all green things to start off, green olive, green tobacco, green peppercorn, cured meats, fruit hidden. Had a hunch and let it sit a day and oh my. Beautiful berry fruit, florals, cured meats, and all the green notes had integrated into the wine rather than on top of it resulting in a wine with an ethereally silky body and elegant presence. It totally caught me off guard. If you stop and think about it you can pick out all the notes, otherwise it is easy to be transfixed by the silky tannins and weightless body as it washes over you. Suzy can’t drink syrah anymore so shipped my last one off to Alfert. Perhaps someday he will be in this thread to educate the unwashed masses on the finer points of green syrah.