David,
Thanks for the note. The '15 comes across as the most polished of our Fred & Dora’s. There was a difference in '15 winemaking that is part of this.
Across the board, for us, and many others in N. CA, '15 was a very structured year. I love the vintage and it is more firm than giving. Fred & Dora’s is regularly the most structured of all our wines and a few days into primary fermentation, it seemed impenetrable.
Our PS and Mourvèdre wines have always been 100% whole cluster and pressed off at the end of primary fermentation. With the '15 Fred’s, we had already passed the point of no return with being able to press it off early (as it was already super tannic a few days in), so I made the decision to let the wine go through about 30 days of extended maceration to change the profile of the tannins. This greatly smoothed out some sharp edges while also making the aromatics a bit more classic and refined vs. our traditional wilder side.
I think Fred & Dora’s shows the most interesting vintage variation of all of our wines. It is an exciting and challenging site and it is so small that we don’t have a lot of options.
2014 is very lean and deep. It is just starting to shine. It carries incredible depth for the 11.9% ABV. It needs a lengthy decant and should still have another decade or so ahead of it.
2015 is as you’ve noted above. Powerful and elegant.
2016 at this point is the most balanced of the lot. The vintage was more giving, open, and I think it hits a nice spot between the '14 and '15.
2017 (declassified w/ most of the other '17s)
2018 is one of my fav. wines of the vintage. It tastes almost like a L’anglore version of Petite Sirah - Bright, ridiculous aromatics, mineral, ripe (in flavors), deep, and I think it should drink well early in its life and beyond. In contrast to the '15’s extended maceration, this was pressed around 2/3 of the way through primary fermentation. Its lighter frame didn’t need anything more than that. At 12.25% and closer to the '14’s abv but with the openness of '18 (which is a trait I see in almost all our '18 wines).