Year-Ender (2014) Dinner w/ Friends.

With Keiichi and Vince in town for the holidays (from Tokyo & Vancouver, respectively), the guys got together for our annual year-ender dinner on Monday the 29th December 2014. The unanimous choice of venue was Mamou Too! in Rockwell - the private room, specifically, so we wouldn’t have to deal with the seating shifts, and avoid disturbing other diners should things start to get a bit loud.

Keiichi, me, Richard, J-Lab, Aaron, Miguel, Vince, & Jojo.

The moment I arrived, J-Lab, who is very much into sherry, shared some of Bodegas Lustau Very Rare Palo Cortado Exclusive Solera Premium Sherry - something he came across while searching for some of his usual holiday fruitcake at Marks & Spencer. Dry, nutty, quite smooth - definitely a nice apéritif, and inexpensive to boot. What more could one ask for (especially since palo cortados are very ordinarily very difficult to come by in these parts)? He thoughtfully let me take home the rest of the bottle since he knows Catha loves her sherry. Thanks again, J-Lab!

As always, some bubbly to welcome everyone to table: Champagne Laurent-Perrier Cuvée Rosé Brut - J-Lab’s bottle. One of the neater, more focused locally available non-vintage rosé bubblies, this shows charming strawberries, cherry and slight black currant. Notable freshness, tension, and vibrance. Light-footed. Very pleasant, if a tad linear at this point.

2000 Taittinger Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs - Keiichi’s bottle. Very expressive on nose and palate, this is a minerally, complex vintage bubbly that presents vivid apple and ripe pears with, after time in the glass, moderate spiciness as well as discreet nutty undertones. Well rounded and precisely ripe, with notable heft especially on mid-palate, it retains good focus through to the finish. Very nice, and, to my mind, will gain even more complexity in years to come.

Healdsburg Harvest Salad (para healthy).

Spaghetti Bottarga - a favourite of the group. With it…

2006 René & Vincent Dauvissat Chablis 1er Cru La Forest - Jojo’s bottle. I liked this a lot with the pasta. There is a bit of softness showing in the flint and white mineral touched fruit base (which, curiously for me, included a bit of pineapple), but it is in good form. Not as nervous or dry as I usually prefer my Chablis, but its acid balance gave lift enough to cut through the creaminess/oiliness of the rich bottarga pasta, and the finish cleansed/refreshed the palate well for the next bite. Lovely pairing.

Some Grilled Lamb Chops before the steaks.

Unfortunately, my bottle of 1988 Domaine Louis Trapet Grand Cru Chambertin was not a healthy one - its murkiness signalled it so when I decanted it. Too pruney and tired on the palate. Still drinkable if one had to push things, but that’s not what it is all about after all. I gave it a good amount of time to show whatever it still had (if any), but, ultimately, I chucked my glass of it as well as the rest of the bottle. Too bad; but, that’s the way it goes. Anyway, I had brought another red for the steaks (more on that later).

1982 Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande - Aaron’s bottle, and an excellent specimen at that. I’ve had this wine many, many times throughout the years, and, though we’ve noted a bit of bottle variation, this bottle was one of the better, fresher ones in the past, say, 5 years. Polished, complex, harmonious, precisely balanced, cassis, cherry, bit of raspberry, cedar, bit of warm asphalt, pencil lead, pipe tobacco, liquorice, leather, and violets. Beautiful wine, very complete. Excellent with the lamb chops.

28-Day Dry-Aged USDA Prime Porterhouse.

2005 Tenuta San Guido Sassicaia - Miguel’s bottle. Quite impressive with the rich steaks. It certainly had enough power and acid cut for them. Bordering on full body, this showed firm structure, good bones, and properly discreet power. Good depth of fruit as well, finely laced with earthy tobacco and a bit of dried herbs. Ripe enough, but not over-ripe (which is a good thing for me). With the steaks, this was my favourite pairing red of the evening.

2000 Château Léoville Poyferré - Keiichi’s bottle. Typically ripe for the vintage, and plushly made with an international slant typical of the producer (based on vintage 1996 onward in my experience/to my recollection). This is a crowd pleaser, and seemingly made to be as such with its luxurious texture and very evident oak-related chocolate/vanilla notes. Very enjoyable, if not quite intellectual. Don’t get me wrong - this definitely has its place on table, depending on the evening’s mood. After all, one doesn’t feel like having intellectual discourse all the time (well, I don’t, anyway). It was good with the steaks as well.

2004 Dominus - J-Lab’s bottle. Another relatively young wine, though, with the rich steaks, as impressive as Migs’ 2005 Sassicaia. More stylish, riper/sweeter/creamier in fruit, a bit lower in acid, this is squarely full-bodied, with an over-all more opulent nature than the two previously mentioned reds (this is Napa Valley after all). That said, it definitely showed good bones, body, length, and confidence. As stated, I was also impressed how well it showed with the steaks. Nice, nice.

By then, Johnny had caught up, and, as we were already very low on reds, I opened my 1993 Robert Mondavi Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve - This is a steady reliable Napa cab which, from recent, previously opened bottles (at Mamou Too! as well), has still got gas in its tank enough for a few/several more years, though I see no reason to purposefully hold back on opening them now with steaks. Just a little bit blocky as compared to its more Bordeaux-esque 1992 version, the '93, however, seems to hold longer in glass. Nothing to complain about, really, especially at its reasonable price, but, honestly, I fee no compulsion to buy more of it. Decent, but nothing exciting.

Others on deck, most handed a suspended sentence.

Richard Joye with a bottle of almost the same name.

Thereafter, a bottle of Petit Grain Muscat de Saint Jean de Minervois Vin Doux Naturel - Richard’s bottle. Pleasant honeyed peach, yellow apricot, table grapes, touched with orange blossom notes. Nice pleasant, simple, straightforward little wine.

Vince seemed to like it well enough.

As always, our favourite Pecan Pie w/ Schlag for dessert.

Keiichi digs in happily.

J-Lab then offered up a bottle of W & J Graham’s 1983 Vintage Port, but we all felt we had had enough and didn’t want to waste his bottle. Thus, this lives for another day.

Great dinner, guys! Here’s to 2015!

Miguel, Richard, Keiichi, & Elbert.

Still reluctant to call it a night, a bunch of us moved to Elbert’s Cigar & Whisky Lounge (a.k.a., the Riedel Room)…

…for cigars and cognac…

…with Alex & Sanju catching up with single malts.

Alex, known for his prodigious appetite for single malts, as well as overly generously sharing the same (at times even surreptitiously) with friends, is fondly called “Demonio” (i.e., “Demon”) - as can be seen on his bottles’ name tags in Elbert’s.

By around 3am, the remaining 4 of us (Alex, Sanju, Miguel, & I) got hungry again, and so moved on to Donu Korean Grill which is open 24/7. Alex and Sanju being the regulars, Migs and I let them do all the ordering and grilling…

…as Migs “wastedly” looks on.

Love the Grilled Pork Cheeks especially.

The super crispy Korean Fried Chicken wasn’t bad either…

…as was the Korean Vegetable Pancake.

It wouldn’t be a complete Asian meal without a bit of rice, in this case, a couple of shared orders of Kimchi Rice. With all these, we polished off a few bottles of the house Makgeolli (a ubiquitous, sweetish Korean rice wine that looks milky and has a distinctive fermented, yoghurt-reminiscent tang to it). By around 5am, we finally called it a night and headed home (thank God for drivers as there’s no way any of us could have safely driven ourselves home). What a night! Until the next!

That’s quite the way to end the year! Thanks for the great read and mouthwatering pictures. I think I will have to have a steak sooner than later.

My pleasure, Chris. Quite a loaded night, to be sure, but, once or a few times a year’s not bad.

Enjoy your steak!

Best,

N

Gotta admire your stamina. Thanks for posting so many interesting notes. Always a good read, and the pictures are a real bonus.

Thank you, Bill. As to my “stamina”, well, what can I say? Many years of hard, dedicated training. Heh heh I’ve certainly done a lot worse, but that all changed when I got a semi-recurring inner ear concern in late April 2010. Truth is, nights like these are few and far between the past 4+ years. I still drink around twice a week, sometimes thrice, but nowhere near the volume I used to.

All my pleasure on the notes and photos. It’s always nice to know someone enjoys them.

Best,

N

So many of us enjoy your notes. Thank you for taking the time to post them along with the photos.

My pleasure, Diane, and thank you for the kind words. The photos are taken with just my phone camera, would you believe? So very convenient. It certainly beats having to lug around a camera (which is what I used to do in the past). This way, just a few quick, hopefully inconspicuous clicks, then, phone back in pocket, and I can proceed to enjoy each course.

Best,

N

Great write up, really enjoyed it. These type of events are wonderful. Just out of curiosity, did you take written notes during the evening or recall each wine from memory? Very impressive!

Another fine dinner! =)

I love that around 3 AM, you ended up having another dinner. As if the first one wasn’t enough! Some great wines. All the bottles sound amazing.

I have many positive comments to say about your post, but I’ll just limit it to, (1) that’s what I like about Poyferre, it’s to drink not to study, like an old school California cab that way, and (2) any red wine would taste great with that Porterhouse. Wow.

I’m glad to know my group of friends isn’t the only one to occasionally have a second dinner in the late hours. The whole evening looks like a blast. I always enjoy your posts.

Noel-

As always, I read your posts and end up hungry. The wines look beautiful too, but my God that food…

Thanks, Dave. No, no written notes (except a line or two on some of them in my FB album, which I posted the morning after) as this dinner was relatively recent. It also helps that I am familiar with the producers in varying degrees. As to my memory, it’s always been pretty good (which helped a lot in law school, and continues to be helpful in practicing my profession) - though, admittedly, not as much as it used to be.

Thanks, Ashish! It was actually I who called for a bite after finishing up at the bar. Yes, there certainly were good bottles that night - except my unhealthy '88 Trapet Chambertin, unfortunately.

Agreed on the Poyferré, George.

Now that you mentioned, I’m imagining now one of Tempier’s reds would probably be great with the porterhouse too! Thanks!

Thanks, Doug! Yes, 2nd dinners (much more substantial than a midnight snack, right?) are great - especially after a long post-1st dinner stint at a bar. Diet-wise, it evens out anyway as I wake up late, skip breakfast, and go straight to lunch the next day.

Thanks, Anthony! The wines were, indeed, very good with the food. I’m pretty sure all who brought the reds were thinking about the lamb and the steaks. This particular restaurant is the one we usually choose when in the mood for steaks (though their lamb and bottarga pasta are very nice as well; and, when they happen to have live Maine lobsters there, we bring nice white Burgs).

Best to all,

N

I just miss the southern hemisphere. We are simply doing it wrong here; I am not holding my breath waiting for my next two-dinners-case-of-wine-plus-cigar-bar night out. Best to you in 2015.

Thanks, Glenn, and to you, Melinda, & Solly as well!

I have no idea when I’ll be back in SF (earliest would probably be December of this year), but, if you are ever in my corner of the world, we can do that for sure, as many times as you want (or can - ask Clem Nieto, I kid not).

Best,

N

Noel,
Great to have you back posting, I, like many others, love your detailed and precise notes. Have a great 2015 and many more gatherings with friends and family.

Thank you, Mike; I’m happy you enjoy my posts! It’s good to be back, and will keep at regular posting for so long as work allows.

The best for 2015 to you and yours as well!

N

Noel,
Please keep me in the loop when you come to the states or Canada. I will be there for sure.
Be Well!!

You got it, Mike. Thanks, you too!

Best,

N

Haha, yes, I’d say it’s more than a snack. That’s exactly my approach on the rare occasion that it happens.