Wine Berserkers - international wine social media, online community, and discussion

Max S.

Michael Martin wrote: ↑
August 3rd, 2020, 7:04 pm
And I will now refer to opening a bottle as de-corking.

I don't know if you're joking or not, but I do like the sound of de-corking. It rolls off the tongue...

Max S.

Below is the sheet as of 8/2/20 at 8:00 PM. Note I was aiming for actual bottles, but a few people called out general regions or producers so I added those as best I could.

EDIT 8/3/20: Updated Beau Rivage

Max S.

Brian S t o t t e r wrote: ↑
July 27th, 2020, 1:29 pm
Max, what happened to the spreadsheet? I can't access it in Google drive anymore.

That's weird, should still be up. I'll repost tonight when I'm done updating. Sorry about that.

Max S.

AD Northup wrote: ↑
August 1st, 2020, 8:45 pm
Really good pricing on Tempier rose today, especially the magnums. Also first time I’ve seen it offered in 375’s

Does Tempier show well young or is its value really with age?

Max S.

I tried a bottle of No. 12 tonight, and I have to agree that the wine is not enjoyable. It's oaky, harsh, simple, and sweet - it tastes like, well, a $10 dollar wine. This was the first of the 6 cases I have bought to arrive, with the rest on summer hold. I'm hoping that the No. 12 is just a bad wi...

Max S.

Jake Rubash wrote: ↑
July 31st, 2020, 5:09 pm
Better late than never?

I appreciate this.

Also, that's what she said.

Max S.

Also, this kind of grinds my gears a little bit: Vranken said the very essence of champagne marketing -- as a drink quaffed at parties and weddings -- needs to be re-evaluated to reflect the new normal: Fewer festivities and a lack of celebratory group events. I understand you can get a bottle of Ch...

Max S.

Hellllo cheap Champagne... they'll take their licks just like we all are, but 2021 should be a better year for everyone.

Max S.

My attitude on these releases is that they are $10-$15 daily drinkers with a fun story that hopefully are great value at these prices. If I was hoping for $100 bottles with every release I think I would probably be disappointed, but I’ve got lower expectations and hopefully will be pleasantly surpr...

Max S.

Yao C wrote: ↑
July 14th, 2020, 10:37 pm
Snagged a Marguet Shaman mag! Looking forward to burying it for a few years...

Should I reconsider not having gotten a 750?

Also, does anyone have thoughts on the 2017 (or 2018) Robert Chevillon Bourgogne Rouge? Normally I wouldn't bite, but checking CT it seems like a solid value...

Max S.

Paul Gordon wrote: ↑
July 31st, 2020, 10:58 am

Doug Uno wrote: ↑
July 30th, 2020, 9:21 pm

M a x S w o m l e y wrote: ↑
July 30th, 2020, 5:55 pm

Library please. Pretty please.
YES!!!
Doug, David, Max,

We hold back very little from previous vintages. We do have some magnums though, which we will likely offer in the fall.

Paul

Thanks Paul! May try and pick some up at retail, thought I saw some 2015s for close to 2018 price.

Max S.

Realistically some deals are going to be better than others. I figure if he says a bottle is 75 at a winery, I could probably get it at retail for 40-50, and thus its worth it at 25 all-in. The margins are going to be smaller for a cheaper wine so it may not be worth it. Buyer beware, but in general...

Max S.

Robert.A.Jr. wrote: ↑
July 30th, 2020, 5:49 pm
I think I have the 2018 but we may need more offers!!’

Library please. Pretty please.

Max S.

This post makes me want to visit Halcon even more.

Max S.

De Negoce has definitely raised the bar for me on deals for CA cabs / pinots, especially mystery stuff. Tough to pull the trigger without having reasonable confidence in who the producer is I'm with you, not that I ever went for the Garagiste mysteries based on what I've heard here. Also we apparen...

Max S.

First Zin is out...

Max S.

This guessing game isn't nearly as fun as de Negoce's...

Max S.

I just bought #15. I passed originally (as well as on #4) cause not a big Merlot guy but if I'm going to buy 1000 bottles of de Negoce to cellar off site might as well have 12 Merlot. Description is good. Thanks. Is 15 still up? I dont see ant of the old offers available. Looks like it's sold out a...

Max S.

Douglas Breen wrote: ↑
July 29th, 2020, 8:36 pm
Will definitely be looking at the Oregon and Washington offerings.

Very interested in both, I wonder how long that will take. I wonder if it going to be worked in upcoming releases or its a "I'm going to do this sometime in the future" kind of thing.

Max S.

Jim Cowan wrote: ↑
July 28th, 2020, 7:18 pm
An evening to remember.

2018 Tibouren, Clos Cibonne Rose:
Beautiful Provenance rose; dry, flavorful and balanced. Very easy to drink.

Jim, one wine merchant described Clos Cibonne as Frances fresher version of Lopez de Heredias rose. Have you had the LdH and thoughts on that comparison?

Max S.

Victor Hong wrote: ↑
July 28th, 2020, 12:02 pm

JonathanG wrote: ↑
July 28th, 2020, 11:15 am
temps in the upper section go up to 64? That sounds like a crappy product.
Heat rises, regardless of unit manufacturer.

Sure, but a 9 degree differential is pretty significant. That said, you get what you pay for - so keep the good shit on the bottom

Max S.

Based on CT reviews Spring Mountain does seem right, and 94 pts WE/95 pts WS. To buy or not to buy...

Max S.

PSA: If this is the place in Minnesota, I bought a mixed case of back vintage Prum from them in 2015 (vintage 2004) and several were leaking, had signs of poor storage, and were quite advanced for what they should have been. If this is not the same place, please disregard, let me know, and I will p...

Max S.

Damn, Washington and Oregon expansion is gonna be fun! It’s taken all my willpower to only buy one case so far but a nice looking Oregon pinot could break me. Btw every offer selling out in 24 hrs is definitely false right? Not sure why he needs to make that claim, he’s had incredible success and c...

Max S.

My list of great wines under $50 is super-duper-extra long. So long that sometimes I wonder why I ever spend more. Sharing is caring! I always saw $50 as kind of the point where costs were no longer a factor and the market took over, regardless of region. I'm frankly more interested in the under $3...

Max S.

Check out Tarlant as well. I just ordered 2 bottles of the 2002/2003 Cuvee Louis through Lopa Wine at $70 per bottle. I first had this about a year ago and it was wonderful. Worth every penny in my opinion.

Max S.

Imagine my surprise when at the ripe age of 24, I rolled out of bed for the first time and thought I'd broken my foot...

Max S.

I've made this into a spreadsheet that I'll try and keep updated. I'm looking for best value wines at all price points (especially getting down under $20-25) so if you have any other thoughts, please let me know: EDIT: Updated 7/26, made it visible to anyone with link so you don't have to request ac...

Max S.

I usually aim for around 20, but here are some I like: -Raventos i Blanc de Nit Rose (Spanish bubbles) -Raventos i Bland de la Finca (Spanish bubbles) -Sandeman 10 yr Tawny (port) -Sandeman 20 yr Tawny (port) -Aubry Premier Cru Brut (solid Champagne imo for ~$30) -Bussola Amarone Classico -Felsina C...

Max S.

Don't you all know that you are supposed exactly 2 months, 3 weeks, 4 days and 17 hours until AFTER bottling to enjoy any wine? What are you all thinking?!?!? [wow.gif] neener [snort.gif] newhere Jesus Larry, it's 2 months, 3 weeks, 4 days, 17 hours, 37 minutes, and 18 seconds. Somebody almost dran...

Max S.

They already having a bunch of customer service issues can you imagine the mistakes that will be made if you can build custom cases? lol Sorry to nitpick, but I'd classify their issues as operational. Sounds like for the most part customer service is on point. I'd much rather them have op issues th...

Max S.

Kris Patten wrote: ↑
July 22nd, 2020, 8:27 pm

M a x S w o m l e y wrote: ↑
July 22nd, 2020, 8:12 pm
I really enjoy Bussola's Amarone.
I don't drink Amarone often, next time I do, I'll look for one. Thanks for recco.

My pleasure! And from my understanding (this is the only Amarone I've ever had), this is considered more port-like in style.

Max S.

I really enjoy Bussola's Amarone.

Max S.

Anyone have experience with the current First Bottle offer? Looks like the bottling itself is only in its 2nd year, but more interested in the producer if anyone has any info.
WA93
Dr. Hermann Piesporter Goldtropfchen Riesling Kabinett 2017

Max S.

Syrah, damnit. Anybody know what's with the skipped numbers?

Max S.

Well, looks like Costco isn't selling the Artevino anymore... or is just out of stock. Just saw as well. Wine enthusiast had one recently in their wine cellar outlet. Could be worth taking a look on their occasionally as you can make them an offer. I think I'm going to hold out for Costco. Really I...

Max S.

MatthewT wrote: ↑
July 18th, 2020, 6:32 pm

JonathanG wrote: ↑
July 18th, 2020, 5:59 pm

MatthewT wrote: ↑
July 17th, 2020, 8:05 pm

lol. i am trying to be discerning going forward. but i am a bad, bad, influence here.
I too bought only because MatthewT bought.
Now you all are just trolling me.

Out of love, not hate.

Max S.

Well, looks like Costco isn't selling the Artevino anymore... or is just out of stock.

Max S.

MatthewT wrote: ↑
July 17th, 2020, 5:47 pm
prices keep going up...maybe he is trying to balance supply with demand! anyway i got a case.

I wasn't going to buy it, but then I saw your post and decided if MatthewT is buying... so I snuck away from the family dinner and placed an order.

Max S.

The next one is here...

Max S.

You're all really too kind! I don't really know what to say, except thank you: reading this helped me get through my biannual visit to the dentist, which, as you will imagine, is no laughing matter for anyone who tastes as much Champagne as I do! I've always enjoyed participating here and I'm very ...

Max S.

There is a difference between providing some details about the wines (i.e. the price and CT ratings), and posting the name of the producer. The latter I fear could cause reluctance for producers to work with De Negoce if their brand becomes associated with this model. Personally I've had a lot of f...

Max S.

ATaylor wrote: ↑
July 14th, 2020, 8:45 pm

My guess is Acumen....higher end cabs, 116 acres and organically farmed.

None of their listed bottles are over 14.2%, this is at 15.9%.

Max S.

Mike R wrote: ↑
July 14th, 2020, 8:28 pm
20's description absolutely confirms who the producer of 17 and 20 are. Retail for 17 was about $33, and 20 looks to be $59.99

I'm still in the dark.

Max S.

OG N. 20 is ghost-posted now. Stumbled upon it looking for the pages for dead links on earlier releases.: OG N.20 2018 "Reserve" Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon $216.00 This is the Reserve offering from the same producer as N.17 2018 Napa Valley Cabernet and, of course, is produced with the same Bor...

Max S.

I'm looking at this, but from a lower budget level. Do you have proper storage for the wine? If not, anything outside of 5-10 years probably isn't a great idea. Do you know what kind of wine you like?

Max S.

You folks are being pretty damn persnickety over $10-15 wines, just sayin’. I defended it but 1) this bottle was actually 20 with tax shipping (lol) and 2) there should be truth in advertising whether it's $1 or $1000 I'm a big fan of this venture and have said so. I'm with you in both counts. It d...

Max S.

Just added in a bottle of the 2002 Catherine et Pierre Breton Bourgueil Les Perrieres to the case I'm putting together. Had this several months ago at a tasting with some of the guys at the wine shop I frequent most often. It was drinking very well. I believe it was available for $90+ at retail and ...

Max S.

David Buck wrote: ↑
July 10th, 2020, 4:08 pm

Mike R wrote: ↑
July 10th, 2020, 3:16 pm
Bit on the Pinot. October is going to be... interesting when 6-7 cases show up all at once.
Same here...my first case...Wonder if any syrah on deck??

Yes, please. Thank you.

Max S.

Looks like the Malbec is out, anyone have thoughts? Most of my experience with Malbec is primarily cheap, $8/glass malbec at a bar that serves 1 red and 1 white wine.

Search found 176 matches