I had read about Library and Turley losing it due to Beckstoffer a few years back. I also remember the vineyard tour when we were told that the Cityof St Helena owned it. Perhaps what I read was supposed to be about Hayne but was mis-represented. Glad to remove the errant info. Thanks Mike!
Agree on all points, though I don’t think you need to buy the Hayne PS off the list. It is wonderful, but does not appreciate. You should be able to find it with some age and within $10 of list price ($75) without a problem. That’s helpful since it’s a brick for 8-10 years minimum.
The others are almost as good, for much less. They are tough to get in quantity on the list—I’m offered between 7-8 cases a year, but only get 6-8 non-Hayne PS. Library, Pesenti, Rattlesnake and the Estate PS can be had reasonably at places like Hart Davis, but you will pay a premium–at least $25-30.
All Turley PS will age well. Hayne will last the longest.
Tim, Library Vineyard (vines planted between 1880 and 1920 and interplanted with Peloursin, Cinsault, Syrah, Mission, Alicante Bouschet, Grand Noir, Carignan, Grenache, Zinfandel and a few white varieties) is still owned by the City of St. Helena and is still under long-term lease to Turley. It should remain in the line-up until further notice!
In my opinion*, this $42 Petite blend (AG 93-95) is a distinctive gem and a screaming deal. They tend to age beautifully.
Generally I have trouble at this price point, but I went for the 2013 Hayne PS since I think it will be one for the ages. Opened a 2001 last year or the year before and it was amazing.
Whew (we need a wiping-sweat-off-brow emoticon). Totally agree. The challenge is keeping ones hands off them while they age, but at least they can be back-filled–I actually just ordered two Library PS–an '01 and '02.
What is the story on Hayne? I had heard '12 would be it, but that’s at least not the case. Is that safe, too?