ZOMFG: "World's best wine shop" opens in London

I’m back in London this month, and while walking through Mayfair happened to stumble into a new store with by far the most impressive selection I’ve ever seen. Appropriately enough, it’s called Hedonism Wines. It was opened in August by Yevgeny Chichvarkin, a Russian cell phone magnate who left the country in 2008 after being accused of extortion and kidnapping (he could be shady, or could have just gotten on Putin’s bad side). He’s in the store every day. The former wine buyer for Harrod’s is its director. The very nice employee who indulged my curiosity for an hour told me that Chichvarkin simply got frustrated when he was unable to find a Roda Cirsion at retail in London–he admits he has a very New World palate–and decided to open “the world’s best wine shop.”

The place is very well designed on two floors, and holy mother of f does it have a collection. The “trophy vault”, behind a lock in the basement, includes pretty much every candidate for wine of the century. There are five bottles of 1947 Cheval Blanc, a 1961 Petrus and a magnum of the 1982, a 1961 Latour a Pomerol, a magnum of 1961 Latour, a 1961 Jaboulet La Chappelle, a 1947 Lafleur (seriously??), an AHEM 1811 Yquem (yours for $160K!), a 1923 DRC Romanee-Conti, and a 1945 Mouton. In the main room they have an enormous wall of Yquem, a complete Mouton vertical, 27-liter bottles of random stuff, and tons of Jayer Parantoux. Perhaps the most impressive thing about the store is the breadth of its trophies–there are about 10 old vintages of Heitz Martha’s (including a 1974, though it has a different colored label that reads “Anniversary Edition”–were there library releases of this?) and a ton of Quilceda Creek, old Monfortino and Giacosa red labels and a bunch of Gaja bottles signed by the head of the estate, really old Marqués de Riscal…they’ve got the creme de la creme of every region. It’s like wine porn–you could spend hours there just ogling. Though if you’re thirsty, they have a bunch of dispensers, and $50 will get you a 25-ml pour of 2001 Yquem! For sh!ts and giggles, they even have a rum called “Ron de Jeremy–the adult rum”, complete with The Hedgehog’s shining visage on the label.

The salesman told me they’d been buying at auction and from private collections for many months ahead of the opening. He assured me they were careful with their sourcing and can demonstrate provenance for everything, though if you’re buying on the secondary market I’m not sure what that really means. I didn’t ask about authenticity guarantees or return policies.

It’s hard for me to imagine there’s a viable business model behind this. Considering that the collection was acquired at the top of the market, they must have sunk many, many, many millions of dollars into buying their stock. The markups are pretty high–there’s nothing below $25 or so, and most trophies were selling for about double the Wine-Searcher low (e.g. $1,000 for a half-bottle of 1989 La Mission Haut Brion). But one would think that most people who play in that league would just buy at auction or on the Internet. The clientele would have to be, well, people like Chichvarkin himself, who value convenience and for whom price is no object.

Are there really enough of those buyers out there to cover the cost of their inventory, and their highly qualified and knowledgeable staff? Probably not. But I doubt Chichvarkin cares. It’s all chump change to him, and if he decides to open the world’s best wine store, nothing is going to stop him. Let’s wish him the best, and hope they start putting stuff on sale soon! If you find yourself in town, you have to pay a visit.

Their website is hedonism.co.uk. It doesn’t have their inventory up, but they’ve posted their full list on Wine-Searcher. I’ve posted a photo set at Hedonism Wines | Flickr.

Neal Martin speaks well of the shop over on eBob too.

This is the second mention of 1923 Romanée-Conti on the board this week. Yield was 3 hl/ha, producing about 900 bottles of wine. We know, of course, that the Germans pillaged cellars during WWII and of course the wines would have been distributed to top restaurants and back in the day were not so expensive as to prohibit people ordering them in restaurants – especially after the war for Americans with strong dollars, if there were any genuine bottles left.

What do you think the chances are that any bottle of 1923 Romanée-Conti is genuine? I can think of one source that I would accept as unimpeachable provenance (assuming that the Domaine has no bottle left), but no others.

Sounds like a great place to visit for eye candy. Reading through your highlights though, it looks like the top ten from the Kurniawan thread!

Same as all those bottles of 47 Cheval being real :wink:

The 1923 DRC came from a collector in mainland Europe. He had bought 2 bottles a few years ago from a very well respected dealer in Germany. The first was tasted in a tasting back in 2009 and since he had tasted it, was willing to let the other one go!!

Alastair Viner, the head buyer, has been totally diligent in sourcing these wines, a task that has taken over 18 months.

The lafleur 47 is from the same source. It is an old bottle with signs of being almost “handmade” with ridges.

One of the Heitz marthas 1974 came from a well known dealer in Oakland, which in turn had come from a private cellar.

We’ve now done more discovery on the '23 RC, and as far as we can ascertain, it is genuine as we suspected all along.

I will next contact the current stewards of the Vandermeulens concerns and attempt to ascertain some more information from them re this wine if possible…

OK, Adrian, and where did the German dealer get it from? I imagine the trail goes cold at some point–these wines are 65 and 89 years old. In the end, you’re buying on faith no matter what, right? The only thing you can trust is if you source from the estate cellar.

It was bought from an old german collector who had had it in his possession for a long time - definitely pre Rudy and pre Rodenstock.

But you are right.

However , in this case i strongly believe these bottles to be ok.

Does the store have any wines normal people would actually buy?

Some. There are a handful of bottles in the $25-$75 range–I bought a $50 Pinot Noir from some obscure French region (ie not Burgundy) on a saleswoman’s recommendation that I haven’t tried yet, and also received a suggestion for a Petrolo Torrione (a Sangiovese-based IGT) at a similar price point. On wine-pages people were saying they had a good price on Cepparello. But most of the space looks like it’s given to bottles that are three digits and up–way up.

Adrian,
Is the 1923 VM or the domaine?

I dunno but you can see the label at IMG_0035 | drosenheck | Flickr.

I repeat that “a well known dealer who got it from a private cellar” means absolutely nothing. That could describe many Rudy Kurniawan specials. I’m not casting any specific aspersions. But I do think that the presumption has to be that a wine is fake, and the burden of proof on the vendor to demonstrate the contrary, when it comes to ancient icon bottles with tiny productions like prewar Romanee Conti or 1947 Lafleur. I’d feel much safer about something like 1961 Bordeaux first growths, where at least you know that a lot of it was made and people knew it was worth keeping at the time.

I have actually had one of the wines in that flickr file - the 85 Sassicaia. Wow, whodah thunk it?

Not from magnum. Doesn’t count. :slight_smile:

Bummer, thought I hit the big time.

Dan,
Thanks for the picture.

That is a Vandermeulen bottling at best it is doctored and at worst it is a ake. What was the price? I am really interested as I have two bottles probably from the same source.

The 47 Lafleur is more than likely a fake too. I bet this doesn’t come with the chateau capsule, especially coming from the same source in Germany.

Wine-Searcher shows $10,000, the same price as recent vintages. It’s strange how there doesn’t seem to be any age premium for DRC R-C outside the 1945 vintage. What is your basis for believing it questionable based on my ultra low quality iPad photo?

I didn’t snap a pic of the Lafleur capsule.

The 23 VM bottles were traded around $2000-$3000 a few years back. There is very little premium for age Bordeaux and Burgundy in general. Having said that the 37, 45 and 62 can command high price with proper provenance.