Berserkers,
The Toronto Wine Elitist Cabal ™ paid its first-ever visit to BOSK restaurant located in the Shangri-La hotel in Toronto. Board members Jay Shampur and myself, along with honorary American member Judge Bernard Schwartz visiting from sunny California and their mutual friend Mac, dined on a spectacular tasting menu prepared at BOSK restaurant in the Shangri-La hotel downtown by Chef de Cuisine Richard Singh, who graciously joined us for dessert and Tokaji wine at the end of the meal and regaled us with his background.
Naturally, Bernie brought a California wine while I brought the dessert wine, leaving Jay to supply the other table wine. French wine lovers beware – my love of California reds keeps growing but Jay also brought a specific surprise I’ll get to which blew us away.
RAUL PEREZ 2010 MUTI ALBARINO – Jay’s first contrib. This spectacular Albarino based white from Spanish winemaker Raul Perez rivals the complexity of your best white Burgundy. Creamy melon flavors with a touch of lees and an extremely smooth mouthfeel is enhanced by slight touches of both flintiness and salinity that act as subtle spices to the wine, not dominant flavors. Truly a terroirist wine lover’s dream, you can actually tell it came from someplace. Literally matched every dish I touched it with.
COS 2014 RAMI – Ordered off of the list. This lovely biodynamic Italian white wine is made from indiginous Greciano and Insolia. Very floral, much more so than the Albarino, with similar melon flavors and a nice smooth mouthfeel. Unfortunately for it, it was standing in the shadow fo the Raul Perez the entire night.
CRAGGY RANGE 2006 SOPHIA – A New Zealand Bordeaux blend of 85% Merlot, 4% Sauv and 11% Cab Franc. Jay’s second contribution was absolutely stunning. In no way shape or form did any of us ever peg this for anything less than a Bordeaux from France via the nose, which is quite an accomplishment. Full of red fruit, oak and cedar. On the palate, classic Bordeaux flavors of ripe cherry, tobacco and cedar give way to a tell-tale smooth mouthfeel and acidity I typically associate with NZ Chardonnay that gives away that this is New World. If you’ve had a NZ Chardonnay, Pinot Gris or Gewurztraminer before you know what I am referring to. Regardless, this is an incredible accomplishment for a new world wine.
CAMPESINO 2014 “Las Madres” SYRAH – This was Bernie’s contrib, a more restrained wine specifically chosen to please Jay’s palate due to his aversion to “fruit bombs.” (Pfft to that, I’m with Bernie and Jay Hack!) A Syrah from the Las Madres Vineyard in Los Carneros. True to his word, this was a beautiful smooth Syrah that pulled back on the typical Cali fruit bomb aspects and was much more elegant and restrained, despite still being very full-bodied. I believe this restraint comes from using only 1/3 new oak in the maturation process. Fully forward blackberry and black raspberry flavors complemented by low tannins, typical but subtle black pepper spice on the finish and a smooth but full body. This is a Cali red for French wine drinkers, honestly. I do seriously enjoy power bombs like the Milk & Honey Tempranillo that Bernie brought last time but this wine is also beautiful and does make me see Jay’s POV on proper restraint in a wine. It has all that I love about Cali wine but dials it back nicely.
PATRICIUS 2000 TOKAJI 5 PUTTONYOS – This well aged Tokaji is just starting to brown ever so slightly from maderization but is still a strong golden yellow, indicating it’s in a perfect place to me as secondary characteristics are going to be prevalent. Indeed, this is all sweet fruity apricot for the majority of the rich full body, but a nice seam of acidity along with some caramel tofee and slight tobacco leaf on the finish enriches it. Noticeably missing botrytis glycerin tingle but honestly that would have been icing on the cake for this wine and did not distract with its absence. This is a good Tokaji from a lesser known producer but I must also say that I would rank some others I have had, particulary from Dereszla and Royal, quite a bit higher. Still, a very good finish to the meal.